PDA

View Full Version : Bangladesh Vs Kenya Series; Bangladesh's progress or Kenya's decline? Your opinion


Miraz
August 15, 2006, 10:55 AM
At the end, Bangladesh win the series convincingly. This is the first away series win for Bangladesh in her cricket history. I am not satisfied with the performance of BD team. In each of the matches Bangladesh batting failed to perform up to required standard. Bangladesh need to solve the continuous top order debacle to have any chance in the upcoming ICC champions trophy.

Fielding was pathetic and has spilled two to three catches in every match. Only strong point was bowling and particularly two pacers. They shared 20 wickets between them.

New boys have started their international career well and apart from bowling that's the only positive from the series.

On the other hand, Kenya's performance is simply inexplicable. They fought hard but their batting was simply clueless. Bowling looked more than ordinary. It's the stupidity of BD batsmen which made couple of matches interesting.

IMO, current series win against Kenya does not represnt Bangladesh's true progress rather indicates the decline of Kenya Cricket.

What's your thought?

al Furqaan
August 15, 2006, 11:04 AM
ditto

sadi
August 15, 2006, 11:23 AM
Well said. I didn't see any good batsman in Kenya's lineup other than Tikolo. All the new batsmen looked shaky and clueless against Mashrafee and Rasel.

Rabz
August 15, 2006, 12:00 PM
yes, agree with you Miraz Bhai.
this win against Kenya does not vindicate our progress, but neverthless, a win is a win and especially if its a first overseas series win.
after all, we had to start somewhere.

Mahmood
August 15, 2006, 12:21 PM
Definitly progress, just look at what Tikolo did against us this time. Great improvement.

LateCut
August 15, 2006, 12:56 PM
Both team declined. But Kenya definitly declined more and there is not much hope despite what Samir of Keynia cricket board says. What is astounding is that there were so few spectatotrs. Even my para game has more fans watching.

Ahmed_B
August 15, 2006, 01:00 PM
1)The Batting department did much worse than previous BD-KEN series.
2)The Bowling deparntment did much better than Previous sereis... specially the pacers did great in Faster Kenyan wickets.

In short... this is the summery. So in total... I would say it was not a very impressive show alltogether. Kenya were bowled out low in two matches..full credit to the bowlers. But even to chase 119..BD lost 4 wickets. What will they do against stronger teams? This ZIM kenya series leaving some marks of worry with the upcoming Champ Trophy & World Cup in near future.

Tigers_eye
August 15, 2006, 02:40 PM
Age may have caught up with S Tikolo. He is on the wrong side of 35.

I agree with all of you that this performance shows the bowlers performed better than any previous series. However, the batting almost made me sick to my stomack. The new blood injected to the side is like a breathe of fresh air. Hope they can continue to perform when we face SL and WI. That would be a big step for these young cubs and an alarming bell ringing into the seniors ears including Bashar.

Sam
August 15, 2006, 05:02 PM
I agree with Ahmed_B. We need to concentrate on batting and fielding departments, if we really want to do better in near future.

Sovik
August 15, 2006, 06:34 PM
i didn't see any improvement in batting from both side. but our bowling improved a lot

Fazal
August 15, 2006, 07:02 PM
Most likely both. But atleast for toady I would like to see the +ve side only, And that is

The re-imergence of Mashrafee, only with the ball but also with that bat.
- The admirable performance (so far) by Farhad as well as Sakib. The maturity of Farhad really surprised me.
- The constant progress of Razzak. He is taking every opportunity that he is getting.
- The performance of Rasel, whenever he got one.
- The constant progress of Shahadat (even though he didn't played in this series.
- Ability to say good-bye to Golla and Alok
- The immergence of Farhad and Sakib will create some pressure and healthy competition for Ash, Aftab and Rajin.

So basically all the young and the ruthless (Farhad, Sakib, Razzak, Shahadat, Rasel And Nafees in some extent) performed better than the oldies in general term for this whole tour.

bengaltiger
August 15, 2006, 07:07 PM
i agree with latecut. both of the teams decline--but kenya decline WAY more than b'desh--it was hilarious watching two amateur team play. kudos to mash thou, he was only world-class player playing.

SMHasan
August 15, 2006, 07:08 PM
Lets see in one sentence- batting was very poor, bowling was good I am not gonna say very good cos they got help from the umpires and kenya played crap as well, fielding was poor, we dropped several catches in the series, did field poorly that produced some extra runs,in the end we saw a ray of hope in Reza and Saqib.

crickwizard
August 16, 2006, 05:38 AM
Cricket in Kenya dying. An empty stadium and no incoming youngstars is the proof. When Tikolo retires, they probably will have hard time even beating Netherlands. This win may be historical for BD but does not add much value in BD cricket. Those guys still play the same reckless shots and still lack of shot selection. Only better outcome is getting the 2 new young players in action and them showing the difference.

LateCut
August 16, 2006, 12:53 PM
When Tikolo retires, they probably will have hard time even beating Netherlands.

They got their rear whipped by Netherland soon after their BD trip and that was with Tikolo at the helm. Just before the current series they go beat by Canada!

layperson
August 16, 2006, 02:36 PM
IMHO Bangladesh has progressed during the last year or so but this series win aginst against Kenya was not so much due to our progress but to Kenya's sad decline. Had this Kenyan team been the one like that of the 2003 world cup then we would have lost this series for sure. Problem with us is even after our progress we have failed to keep that momentum and from time to time display antics of the past. We are yet to become a stable batting side which is our biggest downside and the irony of this all is that when we were playing ICC trophy matches ealier batting was hailed as Bangladesh's strength. The way I see it is batting has been of the same standard but bowling has improved leaps and bound and this is why we still see the unstable batting shows even now just like in the past when Batting was supposedly our strength.

Rubu
August 16, 2006, 02:49 PM
About top order not performing right, I think it has little bit (just little bit) to do with having to chase tiny targets. they took it lightly.

sadi
August 16, 2006, 02:51 PM
I guess you can take it lightly once but three days in a row?? I don't buy it.

Umar
August 16, 2006, 05:50 PM
I would've said its progress....if they had beaten Zim. but...now I can say...they couldnt beat zim bcoz they are a bit stronger then keniya. Therefore...I will say only progress we have is...beating keniya. which we couldnt do few years ago. we can gurantee that we can beat keniya anytime now. But can we beat zim?? still reamains as a Question !

al Furqaan
August 16, 2006, 07:02 PM
I guess you can take it lightly once but three days in a row?? I don't buy it.

did you see the way they were chasing 119...scoring at 6 an over???

i think they did take it lightly...aftab's out was chasing a ball he never even should have thought about

Dhakablues
August 17, 2006, 01:47 AM
Kenya's decline. Bangladesh improved otherwise, you wouldve still seen Bulbul, Akram, Nannu,,, instead you see Sakib, Farhad, Rasel like new comers and Mashrafee like dangerous bowlers.
You guys need to be realistic; with one degress with Zimbabwe, you cannot wipe out all the fantastic progress Bangladesh made,, We did beat Zimbabwe in test/ODi, beat India, Australia, Srilanka. We were close with with India twice, Pakistan once. So you cannot rule out all the progress we made over the last few years. Yes, we did not PERFORM during Zimbabwe/Kenya tour as we expected but keep in mind that this is the first tour after 4 months break and the failure was predominantly batting ( or lack of it). Even in that department, it was mostly our top order failing. For bowling,,, you saw the results, barring that Taylor bashing,, we didnt do that bad. And had Rasel got an opportunity during Zimbabwe tour and Rafique found his form, we wouldve discussed something else.

All in all, Bangladesh has proven that we are not at the same league as Kenya anymore, we are expected to win against Zimbabwe. You wont be calling Bangladesh the 'whipping boys' any more.. we have definitely progressed just that this tour wasnt a good example of it.

israr
August 17, 2006, 03:51 PM
The Zimbabwe series was the last thing we required to know for the betterment of Bangladesh cricket. The Kenya series revealed that Bangladesh has somewhat learnt from their previous mistakes, if not all. At the moment, I can still confidently say that we're better than Zimbabwe, and am just waiting for the CT and the home series vs Zimbabwe. I believe evryone of our players are hungry for revenge, and this time, will rise to the ocassion!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!