PDA

View Full Version : News: Shahriar Nafees, Mohammed Sharif out, Mehrab Jr to open, Russel or Tusher Imran set to play Third test!


farhan996
July 7, 2007, 01:50 PM
according to http://www.bangladesherkhela.info/index.php?newsID=952&pageTitle=details&editionID=67 News, Shahriar Nafees and Mohammed Sharif set be out for the third test, Mehrab Jr to open with Javed Omar, Either Russel or Tusher Imran will replace Mohammed Sharif depanding on how much grass in the pitch. I think this is a good idea but not sure about Mehrab Jr opeaning with Javed Omar and Tusher should play no matter what... ( even as replacement for Basher)...

FIRST THEY IGNORE YOU, THEN THEY LAUGH AT YOU, THEN THEY FIGHT YOU, THEN YOU WIN

Rajowana
July 7, 2007, 01:52 PM
hmmmm mehrab jr opening with javed????Let's see how it goes.

sandpiper
July 7, 2007, 01:53 PM
I hope the change will come out positive.

cricman
July 7, 2007, 01:54 PM
Dhur, we're gonna be 6/2 and then Tushar will make it 10/3 and then Bashar will make it 25/4 and than Ash & Mushi will make it 130/4 or 70/5 :(

sandpiper
July 7, 2007, 01:57 PM
sigh....typical attitude of bd fans /:)

Dhur, we're gonna be 6/2 and then Tushar will make it 10/3 and then Bashar will make it 25/4 and than Ash & Mushi will make it 130/4 or 70/5 :(

WarWolf
July 7, 2007, 01:57 PM
Best of luck for Mehrab as opener. Though I am not much convinced to see him in opening after bad performance in the second test.

Murad
July 7, 2007, 01:59 PM
i want to see Rasel in the team.... no matter what.. hes a good bowler.. he could take some early wickets with his good line n lenght. I also want to see Tushar in place of Bashar

cricman
July 7, 2007, 02:01 PM
sigh....typical attitude of bd fans /:)

hmm... your gonna open with a kid who couldn't score 35 vs Scotland along with Javed Omar and then theres Tushar(I have agenda against him - Hopefully he can come through this time) then Bashar who can't score 25 if you gave him 2 lives.

Mushi and Ash, have pedigree scoring against top quality sides, so does Bashar but he hasn't done it in a long time.

Rajowana
July 7, 2007, 02:01 PM
i want to see Rasel in the team.... no matter what.. hes a good bowler.. he could take some early wickets with his good line n lenght. I alswo want to see Tushar in place of Bashar

ye same here:-D

habfreak
July 7, 2007, 02:02 PM
i want to see Rasel in the team.... no matter what.. hes a good bowler.. he could take some early wickets with his good line n lenght. I alswo want to see Tushar in place of Bashar
early wickets? you want him to have the new ball? one step forward to steps back?

Murad
July 7, 2007, 02:11 PM
early wickets? you want him to have the new ball? one step forward to steps back?

He's gonna come after 10 overs anyway.. so he will have the new ball... and also i dont mind giving him the new ball.. His pace is not less then Vaas's and Vaas is a strike bowler.. but he wont start the innings as Rajib n Mash there.. but still i want to see him in the playing 11..

MohammedC
July 7, 2007, 02:11 PM
After reading the whole article I can clearly see Bangaldesherkhela is biased towards Bashar and Pilot. Although Mushfiq has proven he is better off then Pilot there is no mention of him. I agree Bashar was our best player but his time is up and if Tushar does come in he should play in place of him. OK let Mehrab jnr open with Gulla but SN should play in the team (this is BD chance to try him in middle order). Rasel should be play instead of Sharif.

Also I think this thread belongs here Team for Third & Final Test (http://www.banglacricket.com/alochona/showthread.php?t=22680)

sandpiper
July 7, 2007, 02:21 PM
yep, I want to open with a kid. I believe he will thrive as an opener.

hmm... your gonna open with a kid who couldn't score 35 vs Scotland along with Javed Omar and then theres Tushar(I have agenda against him - Hopefully he can come through this time) then Bashar who can't score 25 if you gave him 2 lives.

Mushi and Ash, have pedigree scoring against top quality sides, so does Bashar but he hasn't done it in a long time.

Ahmed_B
July 7, 2007, 02:54 PM
farhan... on a thread opening rampage! 4 of his 3 posts are thread-openers (one of those is merged). @ Such a high strike rate... 3 threads in a day... I fear he will run out of topics in about a week. :)

al Furqaan
July 7, 2007, 03:47 PM
and the selection blunders continue:

bashar should have been droppped as SN has scored twice the runs he has. SN should have been retained. tushar and rasel should both be in, sharif dropped.

zia
July 7, 2007, 04:06 PM
Dhur, we're gonna be 6/2 and then Tushar will make it 10/3 and then Bashar will make it 25/4 and than Ash & Mushi will make it 130/4 or 70/5 :(

Go to hell, man! :-D

RezOne
July 7, 2007, 04:10 PM
I never understood the Sharif inclusion in our team. He bowls medium pacers that are ineffective at this level and his batting is nothing to brag about. I would much rather have Syed Rasel on our team. He has a proven track record and he's a wicket taker.

BD Tigers
July 7, 2007, 04:26 PM
Not sure abt Mehrab openning. He got out similar fashion (inside edge onto stumps) both times. He leaves a big gap between his bat & pad.

I think they made this decision so that they can include Tusher. I'd rather have SN and Tusher play then Mehrab. Anyway I hope he comes out good.

If they go w/ 3 bowlers which will be weird decision, i'd rather see Rasel gets in for Sharif and open with Mash and Shahadat comes in as 1st change.

habfreak
July 7, 2007, 05:39 PM
and the selection blunders continue:

bashar should have been droppped as SN has scored twice the runs he has. SN should have been retained. tushar and rasel should both be in, sharif dropped.
This is Bashar's final test, unless he can perform some kinda miracle. I think he will either retire or forced to retire by selectors after this test..either way...THANKS FOR THE MEMORIES!

If they go w/ 3 bowlers which will be weird decision, i'd rather see Rasel gets in for Sharif and open with Mash and Shahadat comes in as 1st change.
why should Shahadat come first change..care to explain?

Omio
July 7, 2007, 07:11 PM
Dont trust bangladesher khela,
check their forum and u will be wonder, somebody put some X video over their.

Mahmood
July 7, 2007, 07:43 PM
Mehrab is yet to impress me. Lets see if he can do any better than the 20 from Shahriar.

BD Tigers
July 7, 2007, 08:37 PM
why should Shahadat come first change..care to explain?

The only way Rasel will be effective if he has the new ball and when the batsmen are new to the crease where their feet will not move easily. Mash is a default opener. That's why Shahadat comes as 1st change.

Now lets say Mash and Shahadat opens and they cudn't get any wk for 10 overs and then Rusel comes. By that time the batsmen will be pretty well set and they will probably murder his military medium pace. Then again he might take couple of wks. nobody knows.

oracle
July 7, 2007, 08:41 PM
I think Mehrab will get his act together .He is still a valuable bowling option

Rabz
July 7, 2007, 08:42 PM
Mehrab and Javed for openers??
Hm...now thats an interesting thought...
"where the hell the runs would come from?"

AFAIK, both of them are prettty slow batsmen....

well...good luck to Mehrab, my fellow Willesy.

Protic
July 7, 2007, 08:51 PM
Whatt? Replacing SN just when he is showing some glimpses of form? he got passed 20 2ice in 4 innings.. 5th innings might be it ! He should play the 3rd test.. and about Tushar..i'd really like to see him playing..i mean im not a tushar fan..but still.. on the other hand i dont want him to replace Bashar either..i mean bashar is out of the flow but atleast i know that if he scores he can go onto make a ton ..but tushar.. not sure about it. He has an ave of 6 in tests and 15 in Odis. And hell yeah replace Rasel with Sharif.

riad
July 7, 2007, 09:17 PM
Out (Sharif) --- IN (Rasel]
Out (Rafiq) --- IN (Razzak) .... Rafiq wants to go home.
Out (Bashar)--- IN (Tushar)

and SN should come down in batting order.

Mehrab Jr. should be tried as opener for future too.

my 2c

Tigers_eye
July 7, 2007, 09:28 PM
Team ta ki music chair khela? jakey icchha hobey takey jekhaney icchha hobey shekhaney khalabey?

Ar Faruque ki boley? Just watched NTV news where he was saying Bashar made 50 few days ago. What the ...? Does he not know the warm up match means nothing?

BCB shongskar kobey hobey?

esteban_loaiza
July 7, 2007, 10:01 PM
The quality of this report in bangladesherkhela.com is so poor...... The grammer is pathetic and there is a bunch of wrong spellings...... And I can bet this guy does not know anything about cricket...... I think the guy came up with this selection in his dream..... It is a complete waste of time to talk about this reoprt...

Orion
July 7, 2007, 10:07 PM
The quality of this report in bangladesherkhela.com is so poor...... The grammer is pathetic and there is a bunch of wrong spellings...... And I can bet this guy does not know anything about cricket...... I think the guy came up with this selection in his dream..... It is a complete waste of time to talk about this reoprt...

:lol:

nmhimal
July 7, 2007, 10:36 PM
nO way SN out.... tushar will play instead of Shatif,,,, thats it... no need russell... 110/115 km deliver nothin goin to happen in test... just play with 3 reguller bowler.. mash, shadat and rafiq or rajjak.... we either not able to stop them to score 500+ even if have 6 regular bowler in team.. ANT WAY ... I m missing AFTAB in the team...

ottawaGuy
July 7, 2007, 10:39 PM
bhuwa news!

nahaz
July 7, 2007, 11:55 PM
Man, there's so many biased supporters here.pro and anti nafees, bashar....
I think Bashar should stay bacause it would be really good if he could get his form back..he can really make huge scores, and seems to have some understanding with Ash.Nafees too, he might be one innings away from getting his form back,would be a waste to throw him away after letting him play two tests.We do need an attacking sensible batsman as an opener.I think Rajin would be a better opener than Mehrab.Mehrab should stay though.Maybe just have three bowlers..since we aren't getting them out under 300 anyways.But that is a bit defensive...I think Bangladesh should forget about playing 5 days.They should just be more sensible in shot-selection,rather than just leave the balls .There's bound to be a good ball sooner or later.

scoilaheez
July 8, 2007, 12:00 AM
Nafees should be playing instead of JO or bashar

mali007
July 8, 2007, 12:13 AM
If BD play with three specialist bowlers I fear SL will have a chance to make world records of runs in an innings!!! Did you watch Bashar's interview on NTV tonight ? He said that his batting is ok , only problem ----- he is not getting runs . What a HABLA type answer !!!! As per Lipu's ( Ex captain ) advice he should be replace by Sakib.

Murad
July 8, 2007, 12:21 AM
Nafees should be playing instead of JO or bashar

and what is the reason to drop JO? He's too slow?? made more runs than some other players?? your personal problem with him? what is it???

man think before you post something.. u want to drop him when hes doing good.. and u want to keep the player who is out of form??

some of you guys are just too much. even if JO make a century some of u will be like still drop him.. cuz i dont like him...

sandpiper
July 8, 2007, 12:33 AM
problem is , here everyone is a "shobjanta"
I cant understand how people dare talking about dropping JO from the next match squad, while he is holding the third place in batting average in the ongoing series.

http://content-usa.cricinfo.com/ci/engine/records/averages/batting_bowling.html?id=3190;team=25;type=series

Warlock
July 8, 2007, 12:47 AM
sigh....typical attitude of bd fans /:) I thought Cricman made a good point. :-D After all, isn't that what we see in reality all the time? I wonder why they don't drop Bashar.

sadi
July 8, 2007, 01:17 AM
If BD play with three specialist bowlers I fear SL will have a chance to make world records of runs in an innings!!! Did you watch Bashar's interview on NTV tonight ? He said that his batting is ok , only problem ----- he is not getting runs . What a HABLA type answer !!!! As per Lipu's ( Ex captain ) advice he should be replace by Sakib.

Not like our specialist bowlers are getting them out. We can't really get Srilankan batsmen out unless they play a false shot or lose their concentration. Thats sad but true.

Mahir
July 8, 2007, 01:45 AM
I too doubt the validity of this news report. cow crap.

- SN plays, in the middle order ; Mehrab opens
- Bashar's last test, thank you very much. Ok, wont happen... so "rest" him, my god. Let Tushar play there and give us a 50 atleast, my god.
- Mushy comes_up_the_order for god's sakes
- Rasel in for Sharif

'nuff said. cudnt be more to-the-point to reflect my personal opinions.

Foozy
July 8, 2007, 03:27 AM
I too doubt the validity of this news report. cow crap.

- SN plays, in the middle order ; Mehrab opens
- Bashar's last test, thank you very much. Ok, wont happen... so "rest" him, my god. Let Tushar play there and give us a 50 atleast, my god.
- Mushy comes_up_the_order for god's sakes
- Rasel in for Sharif

'nuff said. cudnt be more to-the-point to reflect my personal opinions.

i ditto that....
the only addition to that is that rafiq should b allowed to leave... and in his place.. put sakib... he is one of the left arm bowlers... and has more flight in his bowling than razzak... it is more probable that he will take wickets than razzak... also he is a good batting prospect who needs more experience...

Antora
July 8, 2007, 03:29 AM
yes!!! no sharif!!!!...not sure about nafees........
mehrab and javed opening??????? interesting............

Antora
July 8, 2007, 03:31 AM
als0... why not drop bashar? what has he done? i think nafees has scored more than him...

Sohel
July 8, 2007, 03:33 AM
yep, I want to open with a kid. I believe he will thrive as an opener.

Someday soon if all goes well, and I think they will Inshallah ... but this type of baptism by fire is tough to survive. Then again, what else to expect from incompetent nepotists with a history of moronic behavior trying to cover their incompetence and nepotism.

Anyway, I don't find the report reliable at all. Tushar's definitely in. Abir may be out as well because Faruikka's under the gun, but HaBa? He'll play.

jahidus200
July 8, 2007, 04:37 AM
mehrab junior doesnt have ability to play test cricket. how he get out in both innnings thats doesnt show he have better quality to play test cricket right now. i think he is still young he should proved himself one or two years more . this way he will be help for our team . test cricket is very different .guys i doesnt wants to blame mehrab junior . but i just want to say if he play third test he will do same things like he play second test .

Sadz
July 8, 2007, 04:42 AM
for a little time Ive been wondering who russel is, but then i thought oh yeah it must be Rasel, come on man it was a short thread so at least improve the punctuation of the players. Anyway Im not so sure of mehrab, he ahas got ability but just now SN is starting to get back his form and if he does he is so much more dangerous than Mehrab! Also I havent seen Tushar play so I cant judge him. But rasel was my choice from the beginning.

jahidus200
July 8, 2007, 04:44 AM
guys mehrab is not a good test player why do you guys are not understand you guys are didnt see how he gets out . thats doesnt show he is good cricketr

Sadz
July 8, 2007, 04:44 AM
Couldnt you post this in another thread but as to your views I just might agree although it is very harsh to judge him on debut test even if Ash did get a century on his debut.

jahidus200
July 8, 2007, 04:48 AM
Couldnt you post this in another thread but as to your views I just might agree although it is very harsh to judge him on debut test even if Ash did get a century on his debut.

ok just watch the third test and just see what he did. i wish he will play good . but his batting styl doesnt show he is good test cricketter

Sohel
July 8, 2007, 04:52 AM
Very trollish.

What does the "ability to play test cricket" mean to you? Please enlighten us if you can. Then compare it with a visual account of his last two at bat in the context of other, more "experienced" batsmen in the team.

He has corrected his technical flaws in only two weeks from what I've seen with my own eyes, and has overcome the jitteriness that used to dominate his few chances at this level. That tells me that he has the ability to learn quickly, perhaps the most important attribute needed for our team to date. With continued play, he'll easily bypass Golla and Rajin put together, unless impulsive, unreasonable, and biased perception continue to dominate our so called selection process and the alleged minds of fair weather fans with numbers agreement issues with regards to liberties taken with the English Grammar.

His ODI debut should never have happened with that List-A strike rate, another topic.

al Furqaan
July 8, 2007, 12:11 PM
Very trollish.

What does the "ability to play test cricket" mean to you? Please enlighten us if you can. Then compare it with a visual account of his last two at bat in the context of other, more "experienced" batsmen in the team.

He has corrected his technical flaws in only two weeks from what I've seen with my own eyes, and has overcome the jitteriness that used to dominate his few chances at this level. That tells me that he has the ability to learn quickly, perhaps the most important attribute needed for our team to date. With continued play, he'll easily bypass Golla and Rajin put together, unless impulsive, unreasonable, and biased perception continue to dominate our so called selection process and the alleged minds of fair weather fans with numbers agreement issues with regards to liberties taken with the English Grammar.

His ODI debut should never have happened with that List-A strike rate, another topic.

who are you talking about?

One World
July 8, 2007, 12:16 PM
Ash in his interview actually was not much excited as a captain with inclusion of Tushar Imran. Probably thats the natural Bangalee mentality of holding to the old (thinking SN can pull of a century with all his experience) rather trying a new (TI has a 198 in FC).

rafiq
July 8, 2007, 12:49 PM
I just don't see Mehrab Jr being ready to open on the Test team yet. This would be a mistake. There really is no reason to change the openers.

Shafin
July 8, 2007, 01:00 PM
who are you talking about?
http://www.banglacricket.com/alochona/showpost.php?p=502618&postcount=44

The threads were merged

Ibrahim
July 8, 2007, 01:28 PM
In this situation Tushar Imran might get a chance, hopefully this fortune will favor him.

habfreak
July 8, 2007, 02:04 PM
The only way Rasel will be effective if he has the new ball and when the batsmen are new to the crease where their feet will not move easily. Mash is a default opener. That's why Shahadat comes as 1st change.

Now lets say Mash and Shahadat opens and they cudn't get any wk for 10 overs and then Rusel comes. By that time the batsmen will be pretty well set and they will probably murder his military medium pace. Then again he might take couple of wks. nobody knows.
you make a good point...but again why exactly we have to play a bowler who will (Might) be effective only for 5 overs out of the 8o overs? why do we have to babysit him? Learn to use the old ball or don't play! Shahadat has way more pace and aggression than Rasel...HE DESERVES THE NEW BALL, EVEN IN ODIs!
we will never win on a consistant basis unless we get rid of this kinda defensive strategies. We have to be willing to pick Shahadat's 62/4 instead of Rasel's 50/1. We have to risk getting Aftab in the test squad, even if that means we miss out on Rajin's 24 of 82 balls.
How other teams win is not by the collective efforts of a bunch of medicore players, but by one or two exceptional performances. Rasel is not capable of that, Shahadat is...end of discussion!

BD Tigers
July 8, 2007, 03:08 PM
Rasel is the best 3rd seamer we got for the test. I wish Tapash was fit but since he isn't or other seamers are not good enuf, u have to play what u got.

A team always win by team effort, an individual or two helps the matter but unless u r Tendu, Lara or Inzi...just look at the NZ team, there is no exceptional player but they were in semifinal in the last WC.

Zobair
July 8, 2007, 04:57 PM
Shahriar Nafees should be perserved with for the 3rd test. He has shown just enough signs to suggest that he will soon be back to his best.

Kabir
July 8, 2007, 05:34 PM
Nafees needs to work on his footwork. That's a minimum for him being an opening batsman. If he can be 50% okay with it too, you'll see less of his dismissals in the ways he got dismissed in recent time.

nzfan
July 8, 2007, 06:00 PM
My line up for 3rd test

Javed Omar
Mehrab Hossain jr
Rajin Saleh
Ashraful
Rahim
Tusher Imran
Habibul Bashar
Mashrafe
Rafique
Shahadat
Rasel

Foozy
July 8, 2007, 11:07 PM
My line up for 3rd test

Javed Omar
Mehrab Hossain jr
Rajin Saleh
Rahim
Ashraful
Tusher Imran
Nafees
Sakib
Mashrafe
Shahadat
Rasel

... now tell me how strong this team is... perfectly rounded... and goes straight down till sakib with specialized batsmen... (or even mashrafee or shahadat on a good day...)
the bowling department dosent need rafiq... or razzak... sakib is good enough as they are all left arm spinners... and besides... sakib has more flight in his bowling... and is more capable of taking wickets at a test level...
weve got spinners in sakib... ash.. mehrab...
and weve got pacers in mash ... shahadat and rasel...
NO WE DONT NEED BASHAR RITE NOW!!!!... and NO WE DONT NEED TO KICK HIM OUT EITHER!!!!... just rest the guy... let him play a few domestic games and get his game bak... rite now he is totally worthless in the team!!!...(if he proves me wrong after STILL being selected... id b very happy... but it shouldnt b taken a chance with!!!... coz theres no need for it... give others a chance!!!)

i think this is the best team weve got.... and u can find out wheather nafees is bak in form too....
... as far as the people who are goin all around the place announcing that tushar has an avg of 6... u guys hav no idea of cricket or wat???.. the guys played just 4 games or so... u cant judge a player with just that... and taht goes for sakib too!!!...

so ya... thas my team and i guess its the best possible team... wat do u guys think?

kalpurush
July 8, 2007, 11:54 PM
Mehrab and Javed for openers??
Hm...now thats an interesting thought...
"where the hell the runs would come from?"

AFAIK, both of them are prettty slow batsmen....

well...good luck to Mehrab, my fellow Willesy.

...Sydney: ...upni to bhai dol bhai korey fellen....amader ki hobey ekhon?!!!:doh: :D

tigerpain
July 9, 2007, 12:15 AM
I don't understand why basar is still in consideration..... BCCB dude get a freaken life ...this guy is already fail on acid test ...move on get a new girl friend ...what so big deal we break ups ...

Sohel
July 9, 2007, 05:28 AM
I don't understand why basar is still in consideration..... BCCB dude get a freaken life ...this guy is already fail on acid test ...move on get a new girl friend ...what so big deal we break ups ...

"BCCB" is dead, they can't get a life, "freaken" or any other kind.

PoorFan
July 9, 2007, 05:36 AM
Lets see who get dropped finally, Nafees or Bashar. Though I wish Nafees should play.

Sohel
July 9, 2007, 05:50 AM
Lets see who get dropped finally, Nafees or Bashar. Though I wish Nafees should play.

True, no alternatives in this tour. Getting young Orion to open instead of playing him at # 4 or 7 depending on the situation, won't be a good move. Then again, why are we talking about "good moves".

tonoy
July 9, 2007, 05:51 AM
this is Outrageous! why is nafees being dropped? he is showing signs of coming back. come on we only have 1 test left anyways. I doubt Mehrab jr will be likely to produce anything from the last test. I mean I have watched his 2 innings, and it wasnt that impressive. but then again non of the other batsmen were that impressive either.

BanCricFan
July 9, 2007, 06:42 AM
Orion = Gullu Jr ???

Sohel
July 9, 2007, 06:45 AM
Orion = Gullu Jr ???

Yes ...

Orion (also) = Kalpurush

Imtiazk
July 11, 2007, 07:59 AM
First of all, Faruque and co. should be dropped. The musical chairs method of selecting players they don't like is mind boggling.

Razzak plays one match, Sharif plays one match and now Rasel one match. Who is this Sharif anyway ? A net bowler ? 0 - 109 and 0 - 86 are his contributions. Reminds me of Anwar Hossain Monir. Remember him? Another one of Faruque and Dav's brilliant ideas.

Tushar brought in as a batsman [ though apparently not good enough to get into the 15 !!! ] only in the last test. Unless the unfortunate guy scores a 100, he will be forgotten before the next test.

In the meantime, someone has to tell me that there are 6 better batsmen than Aftab. You got to be joking !!

When will this mafia selectors term end ?

Imtiazk
July 11, 2007, 08:01 AM
Lets see who get dropped finally, Nafees or Bashar. Though I wish Nafees should play.

Neither would get dropped as long as the [] are in charge. Taka talks.

mali007
July 11, 2007, 09:02 AM
Neither would get dropped as long as the [] are in charge. Taka talks.
You are absolutely right !! Good news---- July 31 is the last day for this FARUQUE [].