PDA

View Full Version : [অ] মুশফিকের বাংলাদেশ জাতীয় দলে ফেরা কি আসন্ন?[/অ]


kalpurush
May 22, 2008, 06:38 PM
সদ্য শেষ হওয়া প্রিমিয়ার ডিভিশন ক্রিকেট লিগে সর্বোচ্চ রান ৬৩২ করা (গড় ৪৮'৬২) মুশফিকের ত্রিদেশীয় সিরিজে বাংলাদেশ দলে ফেরা কি আসন্ন?
পাফরমেন্সের বিচারে সে দলে ফেরার বড় দাবীদার যদিও। তাহলে, ধীমানের কি হবে? ব্যক্তিগত ভাবে আমি ধীমানকে আরো সুযোগ দেয়ার পক্ষপাতী, যদিও মুশফিকের একজন ভক্ত আমি।

তাহলে কি ত্রিদেশীয় সিরিজে ধীমানকে খেলিয়ে এশীয়া কাপে মুশফিক কে দলে নেয়া উচিত?

নির্বচকরা কি ভাবছেন?
আর, আপনার মতামত কি?
:-/:doh::)

crikss
May 22, 2008, 07:03 PM
No more WK...what about Mushfique as a specialist batsman :D

djnaved
May 22, 2008, 08:31 PM
No more WK...what about Mushfique as a specialist batsman :D

agree with you, but the returning of mushfique sounds like alok kapali's story........

kalpurush
May 22, 2008, 11:41 PM
agree with you, but the returning of mushfique sounds like alok kapali's story........
How? Could you explain please?:-D

Mahir
May 23, 2008, 01:22 AM
Mushy scored heavily in the DPL, but gotta consider the fact that he looked awfully out of form at the international level the last time around. So if he comes back and fails to put up decent knocks, do we throw him back into the dungeon ? Our selectors (and the overall think-tank) don't usually have a fixed target when it comes to treating certain players who are potentially good enough to be considered the core of the team. They've mishandled marquee players before, and they will undoubtedly repeat that feat again!

I am a big Mushy fan... but as Obayed bhai said, I don't want to just discard Dhiman now... he's been given a chance to play for the national team, so he should be given enough time and chances to solidify his spot (and that means the next two years atleast). He will also have some 50-overs matches in the near future to show whether we can consider him for the Test team or not in the long run.

In my perfect world, I would have Dhiman handle the ODI wicket-keeping duties for the time being, and give Mushy the permanent Test spot (provided that he will take his keeping abilities to the next level soon enough). I dont think we can afford to include Mushy as a specialist batsman in the ODI team. Test team.. maybe, but that depends on whether Dhiman can sustain the pressure in Test matches.

BANFAN
May 23, 2008, 02:00 AM
Mushi should continue to do well in the domestic. Just one season shouldn't be enough to come back. While Dhiman deserves more chances. We shouldn't forget the situation when Dhiman replaced Mushi. If Dhiman does not show improvement at all by next season and Mushi keeps doing well in the next season also, then one might bring him on. But If dhiman starts doing well, he should continue and that's badluck for Mushi. You can't drop someone for doing well.

But if Mushi is doing too good as a batsman, that can be thought over, we have atleast 4/5 vacancies in the batting lineup at the moment.

desirocker
May 23, 2008, 02:11 AM
i think i would be a bad thing to drop Dhima at this point. We is just about to get mature.

thebest
May 23, 2008, 02:35 AM
Mushy should not be in the team now. Let the hunger burn.In ideal situtation he should be selected for upcomig tour of UK. If he is sucessful then we could call him for SA tour. But probably he would be back due to moronic batsmen of the team and more moronic selector. and don't forget he is the Golden Boy according to Bolodkul Siromony JS .

Baundule
May 23, 2008, 05:47 AM
IMO, Mushy should concentrate more on batting than on wicket-keeping. I'll be happy to see him as a specialist batsman. If he wants to be an allrounder, let him practice some spin bowling, a srb won't be bad.

Rabz
May 23, 2008, 07:33 AM
Well, he certainly giving a "sign" of return of form.
Even though the standard of our DPL is debatable.

I'm betting my money on him returning to the main team.

sadi
May 23, 2008, 08:10 AM
If he is back, I want him to play up the order. Mushfiq is useless batting at number seven or down. Let other moronic batsmen like Aftab or Ash play down the order and try their "Jodi laigga jay" thing. I don't think Dhiman deserves to get dropped just yet though. So, I wouldn't mind seeing Mushfiq as a specialist batsman.

Rabz
May 23, 2008, 12:02 PM
Let other moronic batsmen like Aftab or Ash play down the order and try their "Jodi laigga jay" thing.

Good to see that finally we all get to realise that they r just one hit wonder.

I don't think Dhiman deserves to get dropped just yet though. So, I wouldn't mind seeing Mushfiq as a specialist batsman.

I agree.
IF he is back in form, he is good enough to be in the team just as a batsman.
.. but that is with a BIG I F.

Tigers_eye
May 23, 2008, 12:18 PM
Stick with Dhiman. Don't want 4 byes. Mushi can replace Aftab at #3 if needed.

akabir77
May 23, 2008, 12:21 PM
I love mushi. But i think its too soon. But i see the selectors point of view too. They will not care for the players future. they will care only for theirs own. and when they have players like aftab, z and others they will give chance to players like Mushi who scored heavily this year and try to save their ***...

But personally i think for better future he should continue with A team and Others and keep scoring and get consistent then come in the NTL. Instead of getting score in one session and then get back in the team and then drop again... i hate this cycle. If he can't score in the next tri series like all others we will start pointing figures at him again...

sadi
May 23, 2008, 12:25 PM
I agree.
IF he is back in form, he is good enough to be in the team just as a batsman.
.. but that is with a BIG I F.

For me, this IF is a non-issue. Clearly, he is in form since he is been scoring runs consistently this season. I am more concerned about the timing. Is it the right time to bring him back or should we give him another year so that he can polish and develop his game a little more? The problem is our team is "Nun ante panta furay" type of team and doesn't give players enough time to develop. A glimpse of talent, form or good fortune and he is in the national fold. Eventhough he is good enough to replace any of the top order batsmen right now, not picking him up may turn out to be a blessing in disguise.

Rabz
May 23, 2008, 12:32 PM
For me, this IF is a non-issue. Clearly, he is in form since he is been scoring runs consistently this season. I am more concerned about the timing.

Bro,
we all know the standard of our local league.
Putting right mind and heart into it, scoring consistently in DPL for a player of his calibre should not be a problem.

But it does matter into the international level.
We have seen over the years that a decent-to-superb performer in the domestic league all of a sudden struggles when put in the big boys league.

Im not judging him by his abilities, but its more of the opposition bowlers,pitch and playing conditions that concerns me.

niroshu
May 23, 2008, 12:35 PM
Asssa Amare ki keo bolten parben MUSHY Koita Catch Miss Korse?
Or Shudhu Run Dekhle Hobe Na, Or Keeping Tao Dekhte Hobe!

Jaihok Ami MUSHY R Fun Na, Or Khela Amar Valo O Lage Na.
Ami Chai DHIMAN K ASIA Cup Projonto Dolle Rakha Hok & Shujog Dewa Hok.

R HAAAAA MUSHY PREMIER DIVISION LEAGUE Ei Valo Khelse But Academy Dole Kisui Korte Pare Nai.

Eshen
May 23, 2008, 12:50 PM
Janakantha has already written a column questioning why Arafat Sunny (the highest wicket taker in the premier league) has been left out of the preliminary squad, guess what the press will start if Mushfiq is left out of the national team.

http://dailyjanakantha.com/kn.pdf

sadi
May 23, 2008, 12:52 PM
Bro,
we all know the standard of our local league.
Putting right mind and heart into it, scoring consistently in DPL for a player of his calibre should not be a problem.

Go tell Ash or Aftab that. For them, scoring double digits is a success. :)

I understand what you are saying. For me, if I know a batsman has the ability to play international quality bowlers, I will consider him inform even if he scores run against below par domestic bowlers.

zahid
May 23, 2008, 06:12 PM
Dhiman for now. Mushfiq's wicketkeeping was shabby. So, only way he can come back is through batting performance.

Eshen
May 23, 2008, 06:29 PM
Keeping wise, I don't see any big difference between Dhiman and Mushfiq. Dhiman sometimes takes spectacular catches, but sometimes he also makes outrageous blunders.

I guess it's reasonable to wait for little longer hoping Dhiman will come good, but that wait should not be too long if Dhiman continues with the form that he has shown so far. IMO, let Dhiman play in the tri-series and the Asia Cup. Meanwhile, send Mushfiq to England with the A-team and let him prove that he can be consistent in a level higher than Dhaka league.

Eshen
May 23, 2008, 07:15 PM
BTW, I don't think form was the issue with Mushfiq before he was left out of the national team. His problem was him being way too shaky in the beginning part of his innings. Few times that he managed to survive the initial period, he posted good scores. I think his problem was caused by lack of maturity, not lack of form.

djnaved
May 23, 2008, 10:39 PM
How? Could you explain please?:-D

do u remember alok kapali? a guy who scores heavily in club cricket, then get a call from the BCB, then again throw out from the team........ similarly this season mushy scores heavily, but lets see what he can do if he gets another chance. WIll he take the path of alok kapali's story?

kalpurush
May 24, 2008, 12:06 AM
Keeping wise, I don't see any big difference between Dhiman and Mushfiq. Dhiman sometimes takes spectacular catches, but sometimes he also makes outrageous blunders.

I guess it's reasonable to wait for little longer hoping Dhiman will come good, but that wait should not be too long if Dhiman continues with the form that he has shown so far. IMO, let Dhiman play in the tri-series and the Asia Cup. Meanwhile, send Mushfiq to England with the A-team and let him prove that he can be consistent in a level higher than Dhaka league.
Being agreed, I still want him in the squad as a batter.:)

Sohel
May 24, 2008, 12:18 AM
Keeping wise, I don't see any big difference between Dhiman and Mushfiq. Dhiman sometimes takes spectacular catches, but sometimes he also makes outrageous blunders.

I guess it's reasonable to wait for little longer hoping Dhiman will come good, but that wait should not be too long if Dhiman continues with the form that he has shown so far. IMO, let Dhiman play in the tri-series and the Asia Cup. Meanwhile, send Mushfiq to England with the A-team and let him prove that he can be consistent in a level higher than Dhaka league.

Spot on.

I expect GoBoy to return as a specialist batsman soon enough, and form an integral part of our future. Tours with the A Team will only help his sustain success better when he returns, Inshallah.

Dhiman is a mere shadow of the NCL and Academy keeper slash strokefull batsman we all expected to see at this level but haven't yet. I hope his akaimma form with both gloves and bat end soon.

kalpurush
May 24, 2008, 05:42 PM
do u remember alok kapali? a guy who scores heavily in club cricket, then get a call from the BCB, then again throw out from the team........ similarly this season mushy scores heavily, but lets see what he can do if he gets another chance. WIll he take the path of alok kapali's story?
I see your point, though, Mushfiq might do well, who knows?
If performance is the key to get a call, no matter if it is JO or Bashar or Alok, he/they should get a recall in the national team. :)

BANFAN
May 25, 2008, 03:18 AM
...........................
Meanwhile, send Mushfiq to England with the A-team and let him prove that he can be consistent in a level higher than Dhaka league.

A Brilliant Idea !! I also think that will help mushy to comeback strongly & perform.

dash
May 25, 2008, 11:35 AM
mushi cmin back is a fact,
tech wise he is the best bd playa,
he wz out form nd that happens,
but we hs to play up the order

dash
May 25, 2008, 11:38 AM
by the wy pple talk about kapali as aspent force,
but thay forget he still has age in his side,
we hv to change this mentality of throwin out playars thinking they r finished

Rabz
May 25, 2008, 11:53 AM
Dash mate,
can ya tryn writn in full words.
its gettn hard to read wat u sayn

or may be im gettin old.

kalpurush
May 25, 2008, 12:12 PM
Dash mate,
can ya tryn writn in full words.
its gettn hard to read wat u sayn

or may be im gettin old.
y sm hre!;)

auntu
May 25, 2008, 01:15 PM
he should be back

he is better than gosh with bat n Gloves both

Nocturnal
May 25, 2008, 02:04 PM
he should be back

he is better than gosh with bat n Gloves both

can't agree.......
he shouldn't be back now, instead he should play in UK tour with A team.

djnaved
May 25, 2008, 02:53 PM
can't agree.......
he shouldn't be back now, instead he should play in UK tour with A team.

agree, oi khane hobe tar ashol porikkha