PDA

View Full Version : Your Fielding XI (2012)


Navo
February 18, 2012, 05:53 PM
Make a team out of the best XI fielders who are still playing international matches in 2012. (There should be an appropriate combination of batsmen, bowlers and wicket-keeper just as there would be in a real team)

Where would they field? Why did you choose them? Whose team do you think would win an ODI?

My ODI Fielder's XI:

1. Martin Guptill (NZ) (In the circle)
2. Kumar Sangakarra (SL) (WK)
3. AB De Villiers (RSA) (In the circle, point)
4. Ricky Ponting (AUS) (In the circle)
5. Michael Clarke (AUS) (C) (In the circle, Slips)
6. Michael Hussey (AUS) (Outfield)
7. Shakib al Hasan (BD) (Outfield)
8. Kieron Pollard (WI) (Outfield)
9. Tim Southee (NZ) (Outfield)
10. Dale Steyn (RSA) (Outfield)
11. James Anderson (ENG) (In the circle)

Squad Members:
12. Virat Kohli (IND) (In the circle)
13. David Warner (AUS) (Outfield)
14. Brendon McCullum (NZ) (Back up WK)
15. Tillakaratne Dilshan (SL) (In the circle)

**I was thinking of taking McCullum or Dilshan instead of Sangakarra but I don't think there is a need for two explosive batsmen at the top of the order. It also gives a Right hand-left hand combo at the top.

The selection of Shakib is indicative of a bit of personal bias but I needed a spinner and he also has a bullet arm from the deep. I would be tempted to replace Pollard with Matthews (SL) though.

BengaliPagol
February 18, 2012, 05:59 PM
Make a team out of the best XI fielders who are still playing international matches in 2012. (There should be an appropriate combination of batsmen, bowlers and wicket-keeper just as there would be in a real team)

Where would they field? Why did you choose them? Whose team do you think would win an ODI?

My ODI Fielder's XI:

1. Martin Guptill (NZ) (In the circle)
2. Kumar Sangakarra (SL) (WK)
3. AB De Villiers (RSA) (In the circle, point)
4. Ricky Ponting (AUS) (In the circle)
5. Michael Clarke (AUS) (C) (In the circle, Slips)
6. Michael Hussey (AUS) (Outfield)
7. Shakib al Hasan (BD) (Outfield)
8. Kieron Pollard (WI) (Outfield)
9. Tim Southee (NZ) (Outfield)
10. Dale Steyn (RSA) (Outfield)
11. James Anderson (ENG) (In the circle)

Squad Members:
12. Virat Kohli (IND) (In the circle)
13. David Warner (AUS) (Outfield)
14. Brendon McCullum (NZ) (Back up WK)
15. Tillakaratne Dilshan (SL) (In the circle)

**I was thinking of taking McCullum or Dilshan instead of Sangakarra but I don't think there is a need for two explosive batsmen at the top of the order. It also gives a Right hand-left hand combo at the top.

The selection of Shakib is indicative of a bit of personal bias but I needed a spinner and he also has a bullet arm from the deep. I would be tempted to replace Pollard with Matthews (SL) though.

I would say Nasir Hossain is the best fieldsman in Bangladesh.

Posted via BC Mobile Edition (Opera Mobile)

Navo
February 18, 2012, 06:07 PM
I would say Nasir Hossain is a best fieldsman in Bangladesh.
<br />Posted via BC Mobile Edition (Opera Mobile)

And I would agree. Nasir is electric in the field (I think Shuvo is also a good ground fielder.) But it would have to be an XI that is competitive as an actual team, not just a collection of fielders. That's why I chose Shakib over Nasir - Nasir is still a raw batsman and is miles behind Shakib as a spinner. Shakib generally has a safe pair of hands, is quick and has a powerful throwing arm.

This is not to say that Nasir wouldn't be in such an XI in the near future...

Dilscoop
February 18, 2012, 06:25 PM
Ponting and Hussey has been dropping catches that should've been taken by their standards. They are still decent, but not in their prime.

My Squad:

Martin Guptil
David Warner/ B McCullum (if Kohli plays)
Kumar Sangakara/ Virat Kohli
Ab de Villiers
Mahela Jayawardene/ Suresh Raina
Francois du Plessis
Angelo Mathews
Nathan McCullum/ Nasir Hossain
James Anderson
Dale Styen
Tim Southee

Dilscoop
February 18, 2012, 06:28 PM
And I would agree. Nasir is electric in the field (I think Shuvo is also a good ground fielder.) But it would have to be an XI that is competitive as an actual team, not just a collection of fielders. That's why I chose Shakib over Nasir - Nasir is still a raw batsman and is miles behind Shakib as a spinner. Shakib generally has a safe pair of hands, is quick and has a powerful throwing arm.

This is not to say that Nasir wouldn't be in such an XI in the near future...

But it is a fielding XI? So fielding is the main priority, other skills 2nd.

oronnya
February 18, 2012, 06:54 PM
Yeah Nasir and Shuvo are our best fielders !!! Tamim was very good too :( ... But of course Shakub should get selected ahead of any of our BD player !!! He just adds sooo much to a team !!!

Dilscoop
February 19, 2012, 01:32 AM
HANG ON! This isn't over yet! We are forgetting one of the best! Probably the best fielder from the subcon, of ALL era. Hello? Shahid Afridi! And he is a good alr! Ponting and Hussey has been dropping catches that should've been taken by their standards. They are still decent, but not in their prime.

My Squad:

Martin Guptil
David Warner/ B McCullum (if Kohli plays)
Kumar Sangakara/ Virat Kohli
Ab de Villiers
Mahela Jayawardene/ Suresh Raina
Francois du Plessis
Angelo Mathews
Nathan McCullum/ Nasir Hossain Shahid Afridi
James Anderson
Dale Styen
Tim Southee

Gowza
May 9, 2012, 07:36 AM
kallis is a top quality slip fielder, steve smith is an awesome fielder to.

Maysun
May 9, 2012, 01:14 PM
Make a team out of the best XI fielders who are still playing international matches in 2012. (There should be an appropriate combination of batsmen, bowlers and wicket-keeper just as there would be in a real team)

Where would they field? Why did you choose them? Whose team do you think would win an ODI?

My ODI Fielder's XI:

1. Martin Guptill (NZ) (In the circle)
2. Kumar Sangakarra (SL) (WK)
3. AB De Villiers (RSA) (In the circle, point)
4. Ricky Ponting (AUS) (In the circle)
5. Michael Clarke (AUS) (C) (In the circle, Slips)
6. Michael Hussey (AUS) (Outfield)
7. Shakib al Hasan (BD) (Outfield)
8. Kieron Pollard (WI) (Outfield)
9. Tim Southee (NZ) (Outfield)
10. Dale Steyn (RSA) (Outfield)
11. James Anderson (ENG) (In the circle)

Squad Members:
12. Virat Kohli (IND) (In the circle)
13. David Warner (AUS) (Outfield)
14. Brendon McCullum (NZ) (Back up WK)
15. Tillakaratne Dilshan (SL) (In the circle)

**I was thinking of taking McCullum or Dilshan instead of Sangakarra but I don't think there is a need for two explosive batsmen at the top of the order. It also gives a Right hand-left hand combo at the top.

The selection of Shakib is indicative of a bit of personal bias but I needed a spinner and he also has a bullet arm from the deep. I would be tempted to replace Pollard with Matthews (SL) though.

Hmm don't you think Ponting and Clarke coming in at #4 & #5 is a tad lower down for those two in an ODI? Ideally should be at #3 & #4. And I'd pick Dhoni up, because I haven't seen anyone that quick with their keeping. And maybe he is out of touch with his batting, but he runs like a horse between the wickets.

Navo
May 9, 2012, 01:37 PM
^^ That's a fair point. Might have to switch out Sangakarra for Dhoni. Would need someone to replace him as an opener - De Villiers?

On current batting form, Hussey might not make it into a 2012 Fielding XI as there are fielders just as good as him who are in better batting form. Maybe Kohli could come in?

Roey Haque
May 9, 2012, 05:32 PM
H.Amla
JP Duminy
AB De Villiers
Ponting
P.Collingwood
MS Dhoni
K.Pollard
D.Bravo
M.Hussey
D. Steyn
W. Parnell

My fielding XI beats all other fielding XIs.

Navo
May 9, 2012, 08:04 PM
H.Amla
JP Duminy
AB De Villiers
Ponting
P.Collingwood
MS Dhoni
K.Pollard
D.Bravo
M.Hussey
D. Steyn
W. Parnell

My fielding XI beats all other fielding XIs.

With just two proper bowlers?! You'll have to have Pollard, Bravo, Collingwood and Duminy share 30 overs between them! They'll be smacked all over the place. Even the teams great fielding won't be able to stop that :p

Also, Mike Hussey at No.10?!?

Roey Haque
May 9, 2012, 08:51 PM
With just two proper bowlers?! You'll have to have Pollard, Bravo, Collingwood and Duminy share 30 overs between them! They'll be smacked all over the place. Even the teams great fielding won't be able to stop that :p

Also, Mike Hussey at No.10?!?

What you talking about? Collingwood, Hussey and Pollard will strangle any line ups. Especially with the top notch fielding around. And considering how deep we bat, we can afford to get smacked a little.

Nadim
May 10, 2012, 12:10 AM
You gotto go for Steven Smith. This Guy is a real superman in the field.
<br />Posted via BC Mobile Edition (Blackberry)

BengaliPagol
May 10, 2012, 02:13 AM
steve smith is a gun on the field.
<br />Posted via BC Mobile Edition

Maysun
May 10, 2012, 02:19 AM
David Warner
AB
Kohli
Clarke
Shakib
D.Hussey
Pollard
M.Dhoni
Afridi
Steyn
Lee

Lee, Steyn, Afridi, Shakib front line bowlers. Pollard, D.Hussey, Clarke & Kohli can share 10 overs between them.

Navo
May 13, 2012, 10:40 PM
What you talking about? Collingwood, Hussey and Pollard will strangle any line ups. Especially with the top notch fielding around. And considering how deep we bat, we can afford to get smacked a little.

You mentioned Mike Hussey in your batting line up. He's a part-timer at best! A team, no matter how good their batsmen are, need a few good bowlers to back them up. Collingwood and Pollard would be fodder for any ideal XI facing them.

Navo
May 13, 2012, 10:43 PM
David Warner
AB
Kohli
Clarke
Shakib
D.Hussey
Pollard
M.Dhoni
Afridi
Steyn
Lee

Lee, Steyn, Afridi, Shakib front line bowlers. Pollard, D.Hussey, Clarke & Kohli can share 10 overs between them.

This looks like a good team - they can bat all the way down to Lee! Though Anderson may be a good substitute for Lee as a bowler and fielder as he's in better form, is younger and a great fielder.

You could throw in Warner as a part timer as well since he bowled some wicket taking overs against the W. Indes =p