PDA

View Full Version : Test XI vs. South Africa


SportingBD
September 24, 2017, 03:01 PM
It was very difficult to come up with a solid XI for the first test.

Here is my XI:

1. Tamim Iqbal
2. Soumya Sarkar
3. Imrul Kayes
4. Mominul Haque
5. Mushfiqur Rahim
6. Sabbir Rahman
7. Mahmudullah Riyad
8. Mehedi Hasan Miraz
9. Taskin Ahmed
10. Subashis Roy
11. Mustafizur Rahman

Weakness: No genuine fifth bowler. Have to use Mahmudullah and Soumya as part timers to cover for the fifth bowler. This is the best XI I could come up with.

What do you guys think? what would your XI be?

Eshen
September 24, 2017, 04:22 PM
^^ I would go with same XI (Rubel, Shafiul, Taijul, Liton are passengers in the team anyway), except I would let Tamim-Imrul open, and Soumya at one down.

tiger1000
September 24, 2017, 05:15 PM
1. Tamim
2. Imrul
3. Sarkar
4. Mominul
5. Mushfiqur Rahim
6. Sabbir Rahman
7. Liton Das W/K
8. Mehedi
9. Taskin Ahmed
10. Subashis Roy
11. Mustafizur

Max100
September 25, 2017, 01:51 AM
tamim
imrul
soumya/ anamul (draft him)
mominul
mushfiq
sabbir
Liton (nasir should be here)
mehedi
taskin
shubhashis
mustafiz

Rifat
September 25, 2017, 02:45 AM
The Bangladeshi seamers better step up. they have no excuse this time.

RealSports
September 25, 2017, 09:32 AM
I'd drop Sarker, and bring on an extra bowler. Tamim-Imrul combo is the best. We're not going to win anyway, so might as well take a chance, and go with an extra bowler because you never know in the game of cricket. Wickets are important in test cricket.

al Furqaan
September 25, 2017, 12:10 PM
^^ I would go with same XI (Rubel, Shafiul, Taijul, Liton are passengers in the team anyway), except I would let Tamim-Imrul open, and Soumya at one down.

Agreed. Although Taijul has been critical in our home Tests.

Riyad is good enough to be a 5th bowler option. Soumya should not be bowling at this level.

Rinathq
September 25, 2017, 02:21 PM
Disaster waits.. Regardless of the lineup. But since its fun,

Soumya
Imrul
Mominul
Mushy
Riyad
Shabbir
Liton
Taijul
Roy
Taskin
Fizz

Not gonna play Miraz for the sake of playing him. He will struggle in these conditions. And the thing with Miraz is.. He is either on a roll or he is getting smacked everywhere. SA in the past have shown weakness against SLAs so I want Taijul to play. Plus Riyad is there as an offie option. I know you guys won't agree with Miraz out... But that's how I would do it. If Shak was here, then Miraz could've been an auto choice.

Mridul
September 25, 2017, 02:59 PM
Looking at how SA outplayed SL in SA's last home series and the way BD played in the Practice Matches, i expect BD will lose both test matches by big margins. I don't expect anyof the test matches to go till Day 5 unless it rains. 3 to 4 of our batsmen will hit 50s in the test series but will not be enough to avoid heavy defeats.

Match Adda
September 26, 2017, 05:45 AM
Looking at how SA outplayed SL in SA's last home series and the way BD played in the Practice Matches, i expect BD will lose both test matches by big margins. I don't expect anyof the test matches to go till Day 5 unless it rains. 3 to 4 of our batsmen will hit 50s in the test series but will not be enough to avoid heavy defeats.

Point taken.....but now sakib isn't here... it might change the ploy of bd batting...musfiq and tamim knows that along with youngsters..

jeesh
September 26, 2017, 06:38 AM
When does Bangladesh do well in practice games>

boka
September 26, 2017, 06:59 AM
[বাংলা]
খাইছে হগলে দেহি খেলা শুরুর আগেই হাইরাই শেষ
খেলা যেহেতু হইবো হাইরা যাওয়ার আগেই কাইন্দাকাইট্টা মরার কি মানে?

তামিমের শরীল ঠিক থাকলে এইবারের সফরে আশকরি একটা খেইল দিবো,
মুশি, সৌম্য, ইমরুল এবং মোল্লাহ রান করবেই
সাব্বির আর মমিনুল বোনাস

দক্ষিন আফ্রিকা দলে যেহেতু ডানহাতি ব্যটার বেশী তাইজুল খেলা দরকার।
মিরাজের মনোবল টেস্টে নষ্ট না কইরা একদিনের খেলাতে নিলেই ভালা হইবো।

মুস্তাফিজ, শুভাশীষ এবং তাসিকিন এই তিন পেসাররেই দুইটা টেস্টেই খেলানো হইবো হয়তো।

রুবেল, সফিউল টেস্টে কোন কাজের না
ঝরেবকে কখনও সখনও কিছু উইকেট পাইছে,
তাগো দুইজনকে বসায়ে রাখাই দলের জন্যে দরকার।

আমরা নিজেগো যতোটা খারাপ ভাবতাছি ফলাফলে বিষয়টা তা হইবোই না ।

টেস্টের সিরিজটা ১-১ এ শেষ হইবো দেইখেন মজা নিয়া।


[/বাংলা]

Fazal
September 26, 2017, 07:57 AM
[বাংলা]
খাইছে হগলে দেহি খেলা শুরুর আগেই হাইরাই শেষ
খেলা যেহেতু হইবো হাইরা যাওয়ার আগেই কাইন্দাকাইট্টা মরার কি মানে?

তামিমের শরীল ঠিক থাকলে এইবারের সফরে আশকরি একটা খেইল দিবো,
মুশি, সৌম্য, ইমরুল এবং মোল্লাহ রান করবেই
সাব্বির আর মমিনুল বোনাস

দক্ষিন আফ্রিকা দলে যেহেতু ডানহাতি ব্যটার বেশী তাইজুল খেলা দরকার।
মিরাজের মনোবল টেস্টে নষ্ট না কইরা একদিনের খেলাতে নিলেই ভালা হইবো।

মুস্তাফিজ, শুভাশীষ এবং তাসিকিন এই তিন পেসাররেই দুইটা টেস্টেই খেলানো হইবো হয়তো।

রুবেল, সফিউল টেস্টে কোন কাজের না
ঝরেবকে কখনও সখনও কিছু উইকেট পাইছে,
তাগো দুইজনকে বসায়ে রাখাই দলের জন্যে দরকার।

আমরা নিজেগো যতোটা খারাপ ভাবতাছি ফলাফলে বিষয়টা তা হইবোই না ।

টেস্টের সিরিজটা ১-১ এ শেষ হইবো দেইখেন মজা নিয়া।


[/বাংলা]

:up:. Boka, Tumi boroye Budhimaan.

Tigers_eye
September 26, 2017, 08:29 AM
[বাংলা]
...
টেস্টের সিরিজটা ১-১ এ শেষ হইবো দেইখেন মজা নিয়া।


[/বাংলা]Eida Jodi hoi, ami apnar je kono charity'tey $100 USD dibo. Ar PM jano shobai'key ekta flat o gari dewar ghoshona dei.

tiger1000
September 26, 2017, 08:41 AM
Disaster waits.. Regardless of the lineup. But since its fun,

Soumya
Imrul
Mominul
Mushy
Riyad
Shabbir
Liton
Taijul
Roy
Taskin
Fizz

Not gonna play Miraz for the sake of playing him. He will struggle in these conditions. And the thing with Miraz is.. He is either on a roll or he is getting smacked everywhere. SA in the past have shown weakness against SLAs so I want Taijul to play. Plus Riyad is there as an offie option. I know you guys won't agree with Miraz out... But that's how I would do it. If Shak was here, then Miraz could've been an auto choice.

Mehedi needs to play as he needs to do the all rounder leg work, this one tail starts at 8, that's way too big, taskin is a decent 10 maybe a 9, same with Taijul, but others are 11.

We need Mehedi to average 30 with the bat

So I actually feel completely opposite, because Shakib is out Mehedi needs to play in my opinion

Fazal
September 26, 2017, 10:47 AM
Yes I also want to see more of Mehedi. His batting is slowly improving. He need more exposure.

However I have to say Taijul deserve some kudos for his performance in last series. As a fielder, amazing improvement. Bolwing wise he was sligtly better than his past.