Agree with you all logical people. Narine was the the top performer without a doubt. But, my vote belongs to Shakib because emotion wins over logic
There's another reason. Narine will win anyways. But, if we all vote for Shakib, he might get the second position, which might positively influence his odds of being counted as the third preferred foreign player (after kallis and narine) next season.
Please all vote for our man.