[Miraz]

Carte Blanche post mortem is quite allright but I think he was quite generous to Pilot and a bit harsh on Shahadat.

In my opinion

Pilot - F : After such a stupid second innings dismissal when we needed him most and after missing crucial run out opportunity he should be rated F. His encouraging voice was also almost absent throughout second innings. His first innings batting was also below par.

Shahadat : B : He showed real aggression of a fast bowler and bowled quite well. He was unlucky in a couple of occasion and created a real opportunity to take Ponting at a crucial time, we failed to grasp the opportunity. His last three bouncer to Ponting was really very positive.