Much respect for well develop argument.
The argument I was making was for his captancy not his individual performance with the bat. He played above avg during NZ tour but struggled during SA series. He is still one of the top 3 batsman in our team.
NBA drafted a few players right out of high school as opposed to college graduate
- Kobe Bryant
- Kevin Garnet
- LeBron James
- Tracy McGrady
- Jermaine Oneil
- Amare Stoudamire
- Dwight Howard
There are others but these guys became superstars. I do not think having a player in the league early affects as much but it has its negative side effects.
My argument was why he should be given more time as a captain before we crucify him. he cannot win the game alone if Zunaed, Tamim, Aftab, Sakib and others do not perform to their expectations. Our top order collapses every game that has subsequent affects on the rest of the lineups.