Atahar is a decent enough commentator, but he needs to control his emotions or his excitement sometimes, and his voice tone which goes up & down , his totlami , the use of dots.......are annoying,
Shamim on the other hand has a soothing voice , but Shamim is a super sissy, in either 1st or 2nd ODI during the last five overs we were batiing he said smething like "hit it if it is in your zone "
And Ata needs to stop saying Wise-captain , makes the other captain unwise.
Apart from that he is fine.
BTW, is Shamim the only commie who is not an ex-cricketer ? explains the sissyness.