Asad, for sake of fairness, I took both Pilot's and Mushfiq's stats against G7 teams (so that we don't have to worry about stats against Windies-C).
Pilot -
http://stats.cricinfo.com/ci/engine/...s;type=batting
Mushfiq -
http://stats.cricinfo.com/ci/engine/...s;type=batting
Forget about not outs, take runs scored per innings. Pilot comes up with 17.26/inn and Mushfiq with 12.41/inn ! And Pilot actually had a marginally better SR !