Bangladesh Captains (The Great Ones)

[Shamim Mia]

Originally Posted by Purbasha T
Bro, You din't include the pre-test era captains of ours. Also Khaled Mahmud was our captain too for a significant amount of time in early 2000s.

yep but he lost too many games and the other captains made an impact on the bangladesh team, but he is respected.

[Shamim Mia]

Originally Posted by sadhat
What about little "None" option?

y you think none of them deserve to be good captain???

[sadhat]

Originally Posted by Shamim Mia
y you think none of them deserve to be good captain???

In my opinion, BD is still looking for a good captain. I think Habibur was average but too defensive. We always complained about this. Mashud - naah, Ashraful - BIG NO, Shakib - need more time to say he is the one. Two series with two bad teams, the result does not reflect 100% success story.
So "None" would be my pick (but missing option)

[revolver]

lol shamim u joker...man ur a top joke hehehehehh bhai wen is ur next poll??

[Shamim Mia]

Originally Posted by sadhat
In my opinion, BD is still looking for a good captain. I think Habibur was average but too defensive. We always complained about this. Mashud - naah, Ashraful - BIG NO, Shakib - need more time to say he is the one. Two series with two bad teams, the result does not reflect 100% success story.
So "None" would be my pick (but missing option)

when you say defensive, isnt that good for us, as we got all the offensive batsmens hitting at every bowl being bowled, imagine him not being defensive we wouldnt have won the amount he won as captain?

[sadhat]

Originally Posted by Shamim Mia
when you say defensive, isnt that good for us, as we got all the offensive batsmens hitting at every bowl being bowled, imagine him not being defensive we wouldnt have won the amount he won as captain?

I am not saying defensive as batsmen, I am saying deffensive captaincy. You just play and use bowler such a way that waiting for something to happen. Not attacking, not using different options. I know BD does not have much options. But I think he could do better, like Shakib did against WI. He gave ball to Ash right on time and clicked. Some risk, some luck. Well I like Shakib for that, but its too early to say Shakib is a good captain.

[Raynman]

Shakib definitely has a more aggressive and assertive approach than any other captain in the past. I would've loved to see what a Whatmore/Shakib combo could do for Bangladesh.

[_Rafi_]

Originally Posted by nadim 98
shamim mia should be given a custom title for his excellent poll every 2 days.

Shamim mia: "BC poll master"

Posted via BC Mobile Edition

bangladesh is a democratic country and Shamim mia vai loves democracy

Posted via BC Mobile Edition

[AsifTheManRahman]

Shamim Mia, it's not all about the results, it's what you do with them that matters. Maybe it's time to open a poll to decide what we should do with the results of all the existing ones.

[simon]

waiting to see Bashar in this eid natok:
http://www.prothom-alo.net/V1/mcat.n...zMjg2&mid=OQ==

He didn't get the major role as Pilot.
His bangla is very grmmtcly correct, any 1 knows about his eductnl background??

[Fazal]

Mia Bhai Mama barir theke kebolee ashlen... kisu din rest nen...na hoiley apner shuta koi theke koi goray....Bash neye pola poley kora ta ajkal risky...kobey abar bash khaiye hoi who knows....

[Ashraf-FTP]

HB is the best BD captain as of yet.. he had a very good ability of changing bowling at the right time to break vital partenerships..

[fuzzy]

khaled mashud was the worst cap. for bd....

[BanCricFan]

Shamim mia, I should add Salma Khatun to your poll and you have a winner!

[Murad]

How is Shakib the best captain?

He hardly captained the side. Won against two depleted teams and won.!!

It have to be Bashar even though he was depensive at times.

People only remembers the present and forget the past!!

[Foozy]

Originally Posted by Murad
How is Shakib the best captain?

He hardly captained the side. Won against two depleted teams and won.!!

It have to be Bashar even though he was depensive at times.

People only remembers the present and forget the past!!

Not really brother. From my point of view Bashar is the second best. The best I have seen so far is Sakib. Bashar was way too defensive.

Apart from that Bashar almost never changed his batting line up or the overs to be bowled by each bowler. He rarely took into account the match situation. Some times over-thinking can ruin things as well its true. It may happen to Sakib in a game or two. But the fact of the matter is that he actually holds the nerve to try things out or try and play according to game situations.

He is the first Bangladeshi Player let alone captain to think deep into the game. Sometimes I feel as if he is far ahead of all of us fans (who are sitting at home and writing in our wish-lists) in terms of reading match-situation.

....but I do agree with you that he still has a long way to go before we can actually make a solid statement. But my comments were based on what I have seen so far .

[Faisal]

Sakib is the best captain.

[bujhee kom]

Arrey Murad bhai, Bashar is our Sandeep Patil, he is our Hero! I can't wait to get hold of the Box set of the Eid film and then I am gonna bootleg it and make much money on the subway!

[_Rafi_]

Originally Posted by Faisal
Sakib is the best captain.

Hmm. It seems to be Shakib is our driver(c) and mash is helper(vc)

Posted via BC Mobile Edition

[Tigers_eye]

I am so glad to see these two in a car (instead in a motor cycle). Now if only we can have automatic seat belt installed.

[beshideshi]

Originally Posted by Tigers_eye
I am so glad to see these two in a car (instead in a motor cycle). Now if only we can have automatic seat belt installed.

Aste aste motorcycle theke gari te uthse[hierarchy of safety] koedin por inshallah seat belt o porbe.
p.s. considering the traffic jam in dhaka, no car goes past 40km/h. So we dont need to worry as they stay in dhaka.

[Imteaz]

They way Mashrafe sit in the car, seems that his knee injury is in better position.

[BANFAN]

Originally Posted by Murad
How is Shakib the best captain?

He hardly captained the side. Won against two depleted teams and won.!!

It have to be Bashar even though he was depensive at times.

People only remembers the present and forget the past!!

Truely so. Otherwise Shakib even wouldn't be in the list for evaluation.
A captain can only be evaluated/compared when he finishes his term or have been captain for a long time.

[Shamim Mia]

Originally Posted by sadhat
I am not saying defensive as batsmen, I am saying deffensive captaincy. You just play and use bowler such a way that waiting for something to happen. Not attacking, not using different options. I know BD does not have much options. But I think he could do better, like Shakib did against WI. He gave ball to Ash right on time and clicked. Some risk, some luck. Well I like Shakib for that, but its too early to say Shakib is a good captain.

well said,

I agree with your opinion

[Shamim Mia]

Originally Posted by BanCricFan
Shamim mia, I should add Salma Khatun to your poll and you have a winner!

i would have if she played cricket