The post Australia tour Siddons poll

[Spitfire_x86]

Vote for pro-Siddons if you're think our players are more responsible than the coach for our bad performance.

Vote for anti-Siddons if you're think Siddons is more responsible than the players for our bad performance.

[WarWolf]

Why is the option for "Neither"?

[auntu]

So many polls are going on! Pre-election warm up for BD's?

[Dhurr]

Why can't you say the coach is responsible and so are the players? Why pick one or the other?

[Miraz]

Originally Posted by Dhurr
Why can't you say the coach is responsible and so are the players? Why pick one or the other?

Because that's the only way to ensure maximum vote for Siddons.

[Green Tea]

Originally Posted by Miraz
Because that's the only way to ensure maximum vote for Siddons.

So you are a pro siddons.

[Spitfire_x86]

Originally Posted by WarWolf
Why is the option for "Neither"?

Originally Posted by Dhurr
Why can't you say the coach is responsible and so are the players? Why pick one or the other?

Because if you watched the games then you're most likely to think one party is at least slightly more responsible than the other. It's impossible to be 100% neutral.

[BD-Shardul]

Pro Siddons.

[Tigers_eye]

If this is a project, you don't pull the plug midway. At this point obviously Pro-Siddons. Come when his contract expires I will re-evaluate his tenure. By the way, players are to be blamed for this dismal performance. Captain takes the lion share.

Ash's rash shot after getting a live shows he has learned nothing. 110% his failure is on his shoulder alone. After so many games he is yet to know how to build an innings, how to support partners.

[Kabir]

Originally Posted by Tigers_eye
If this is a project, you don't pull the plug midway. At this point obviously Pro-Siddons. Come when his contract expires I will re-evaluate his tenure. By the way, players are to be blamed for this dismal performance. Captain takes the lion share.

Good point. Except for the captain part...see below.

Ash's rash shot after getting a live shows he has learned nothing. 110% his failure is on his shoulder alone. After so many games he is yet to know how to build an innings, how to support partners.

I see your point. But as I said earlier, 1 person rarely makes a team of 11 lose. It's the combined idiotic effect.

Captain takes the bigger share of responsibility. I agree with that. But he's not the one solely responsible. A captain can't do a thing if others in his team doesn't do a thing. At the same time, if a captain cannot set the example, the others in the team won't give it a shot.

[Tigers_eye]

Originally Posted by Kabir
...
Captain takes the bigger share of responsibility. I agree with that. But he's not the one solely responsible. A captain can't do a thing if others in his team doesn't do a thing. At the same time, if a captain cannot set the example, the others in the team won't give it a shot.

Pagol koi ki? Ami captain, ami 1st down batsman, ami team'er most experienced player, ami jodi team'er poristhiti onojai na kheli, how can I ask my players to play the way the team needs? Kon mukhey ami Alok'rey bolbo, "eita ki shot marlen?" How can I say to Shakib, "bod, tui janish RRR 4'er nichey, just tikey thak"; to Tamim, "Abdur Razzak and Mash can easily support you just minimise risk and play your game stay notout". Manmanagement kortey you need to have some weight. Only performance leading from the front gives you that weight.

If the leadership is not doing the job no team/corporation/organization can't ask their employee/player to perform. The ship will sink or go stray. Goals won't be achieved. Comments like, "we are much better than this" will surface. See post match interview of game two. Bankruptsy is a must unless the CEO is fired or changed his tactics. Udahoron dibo?

[Kabir]

Originally Posted by Tigers_eye
Pagol koi ki? Ami captain, ami 1st down batsman, ami team'er most experienced player, ami jodi team'er poristhiti onojai na kheli, how can I ask my players to play the way the team needs?

I don't see a difference between what I'm saying and what you're saying. Except for the fact that you think Ashraful can single-handedly make you lose a match.

That's a bit strong of a statement, IMO

[Rubu]

Where is the option that I could not make up my mind yet?

[BANFAN]

Pro players, definitely not adti Siddon. Can we have that option please.

May be both have to share the blame of repeated failure. Punish, torture, train, educate whatever you need to do to fix the players, do it. You can hardly throw away anyone. That's what we have in our country. You cannot offer a coaching course to the expat coach, neither take other actions applicable for players. You can only change the coach as other options aren't feasible & that's not the only option we have when the whole world is open for you to choose a coach.

It doesn't mean being harsh with coach, every one has their own level of actions feasible for their position.

[cricket_dorshok]

polling time?

so many many BC polls.

[Spitfire_x86]

So far, 71% pro-Siddons, 29% anti-Siddons (counting Miraz and BANFAN as anti-Siddons)

[BD-Shardul]

Originally Posted by Rubu
Where is the option that I could not make up my mind yet?

Come to poll after you make your mind

[bujhee kom]

may Allah and his beautiful nature bless the tigers and our coach siddons!
how often can you vote?

[BD Tigers]

Coach cannot do crap if players dont use their brain. In the last game all they had to do is play 50 overs, THAT's IT. 50 overs. Why go for domination? Whats the point when RR is only below 4? I am sure Coach didn't tell them that.

[Foozy]

lol i voted in the wrong column by mistake

[MohammedC]

Originally Posted by Foozy
lol i voted in the wrong column by mistake

Dont worry you now have 2 vote. One that you just clicked and the one that you were supposed to.

You have the option to change side if Siddons fail. Big If

[Baundule]

Tricky poll. Vote dane biroto thaklam. Both parties are responsible. The question about 'more responsibility' sounds like who did more damage to Bangladesh, BNL or AL.

[crikfreak]

pro- siddoms i think.. on the whole.. i think the players are more to blame on their abysmal performance..

[scoilaheez]

I hope people continue to support siddons because u can blame the coach all day long, at the end of the day our players have to take more responsibility for their actions.

[nsd3]

'MULA MULI' on Siddons criticism was halted after JS interview was published on bc recently. I hear nothing whatsoever.