self-assessment- why my name has not been mentioned in the favourite list

[Sorry]

Many members are disappointed not see their names mentioned in the other thread being the favourite poster. I have carried out a mini research and decided to post my questionnaire and answers in order to find out why others have not been mentioned. Please keep in mind that the duration of research was only 20 mins.
Please take the self-assessment and let me know the outcome frankly.
1. the duration of your BC membership is:
a. more than 3 years
b. 2-3 years
c. 1-2 years
d. less than 1 year

2. the total number of your posts:
a. more than 4000
b. 2000-3000
c. 1000-2000
d. less than 1000

3. your avatar is:
a. funny
b. unique
c. doesn’t make sense
d. no avatar

4. do you post in
a. bangladesh cricket
b. Bangladesh + international cricket
c. Bangladesh + international cricket+ forget cricket
d. All forums

5. your post is always positive about
a. moderator + oldies +bd cricket fans+bd cricket
b. moderator and oldies only
c. bd fans only
d. when appropriate

6. number of ban warnings you have received
a. 3 times
b. 2 times
c. 1 time
d. none

7. out of last five threads you posted, the number of responses you have received
a. very good
b. good
c. satisfactory
d. abusive

8. when you are posting, the most important thing that comes in your head
a. be neutral and constructive
b. be bias
c. be critical
d. be funny

9. the number of members you have personal communication with
a. more than 100
b. 50-100
c. 1-50
d. none

10. number of times you got in trouble with a member
a. more than 10 times
b. 10-5
c. 5-1
d. none

11. what topic interest you the most
a. funny
b. controversial and bias
c. constructive
d. all above


here are the scores for each question:
1.
a.4
b.3
c.2
d.1

2.
a.4
b.3
c.2
d.1

3.
a.3
b.4
c.2
d.1

4.
a.1
b.2
c.3
d.4

5.
a.3
b.2
c.1
d.4

6.
a.3
b.2
c.1
d.4

7.
a.4
b.3
c.2
d.0

8.
a.4
b.2
c.1
d.3

9.
a.4
b.3
c.2
d.0

10.
a.1
b.2
c.3
d.4

11.
a.3
b.2
c.1
d.4

now calculate your scores and look at the next post for answers.
related thread: http://www.banglacricket.com/alochon....php?tid=14611

Edited on, October 26, 2005, 10:15 PM GMT, by banglar_dorbesh.

[Sorry]

Answers:
If you have scored:
44-35 you have already been mentioned in the favourite list
34-25 you are nearly there
24-15 keep improving
14-0 needs overtime working

umpire's decisions:
1. if you have scored 44-35 but have not been mentioned yet , consider this as arrogance of BC members.
2. if you have scored less than 25 but have been mentioned once only, please consider this as a fluke or the quality of the posts wasn't the main reason.
3. if you have scored 34-25 but have been mentioned more than once, please consider this a marginal error of this assessment
4. if you have scored less than 15 but have been mentioned, probably you have been mentioned by a controversial or causioned member( got multiple ban warnings).

Edited on, October 27, 2005, 6:57 AM GMT, by banglar_dorbesh.
Reason: score adjustment


Edited on, October 27, 2005, 10:58 AM GMT, by banglar_dorbesh.
Reason: addition of umpire's decisions

Edited on, October 27, 2005, 10:00 PM GMT, by banglar_dorbesh.

[fab]

I got 25.. so I need to work overtime?

[Sorry]

Edited on, October 26, 2005, 11:10 PM GMT, by banglar_dorbesh.

[Sorry]

please note that the assessment requires 100% honest answers.

Edited on, October 26, 2005, 11:14 PM GMT, by banglar_dorbesh.

[Mahmood]

I scored 36, yet I was mentioned!

Are you sure this thing works!

[Rubu]

i got 38 and mentioned! so the scale should be adjusted a bit.

[PoorFan]

got only 31! poor me

[oracle]

There are many worthy causes out there. And the list is too long. I sometimes feel guilty for a lot of things and the amount of time i waste.
Popularity, or whatever in Banglacricket, or whatever forum is definetely a joke.






Edited on, October 27, 2005, 5:46 PM GMT, by oracle.

[bourny3]

i got 27 i think/

[Sorry]

thanks to fab, mahmood, oracle, rubu, poorfan, bourny3 for early responses. it was valuable to have these feedback in order to make the necessary adjustment and it should work perfectly now.

[Fazal]

Good Job banglar_dorbesh !!!

Very interesting observation and topic.

btW have you pattended yet??? If not do it asap.

I scored 30. That means I am in "34-25 you are nearly there" range.

So its not all fluke ... there is some hope for me after all to go to the next range.

[Hatebreed]

I got 28 so I guess I'm nearly there!... I don't think I'll be anyone's favourite unless I personally befriend the thread starter with some pump-potti combined with the finest Keshoboti shugondhi tel...

besides it's natural in many forums where the 'big bros' (by experience, age, etc) form sort of a gang and over or underrate others..

*sings like jim carey* don'chu want somebody to looooove? doooon'chu u need soomebody to loooove!!!

[Tigers_eye]

I scored a 29. Happy with the score.

Feedback for Dorbesh bhai.

#9. Noway to get a 4. Personal communication with 100+ members is not possible. (I scored a zero on that. Grrrrr.)

#7. may be tweak it a little bit and put response # beside it. My "Very good" may be mods "satisfactory". I know they hold themselves to a higher standard.

Good thread.

[AsifTheManRahman]

I scored a 38, but thought i set myself standards that were a bit on the high.

[AsifTheManRahman]

as a matter of fact i was actually confused with some of them, and didn't know what to say, so refrained from giving myself the benefit of doubt

[Sorry]

Originally posted by Fazal
Good Job banglar_dorbesh !!!

Very interesting observation and topic.

btW have you pattended yet??? If not do it asap.

I scored 30. That means I am in "34-25 you are nearly there" range.

So its not all fluke ... there is some hope for me after all to go to the next range.

i scored 24.
questions 1,2,4,7,9 put me down. out of 5 questions i scored only 4 points!
btw thanks for your comments.

[Tintin]

I got 20

[Sauron]

Originally posted by Tintin
I got 20

Man! That is like almost 20 points more than what I got!

[Sorry]

Originally posted by Cats_eye
I scored a 29. Happy with the score.

Feedback for Dorbesh bhai.

#9. Noway to get a 4. Personal communication with 100+ members is not possible. (I scored a zero on that. Grrrrr.)

#7. may be tweak it a little bit and put response # beside it. My "Very good" may be mods "satisfactory". I know they hold themselves to a higher standard.


Good thread.

#9. this is a good point. the range should have been smaller. BTW, i scored 0 as well on this question.

#7. we have to give new members a chance to score a few points. oldies will take all the points from questions 1 and 2.

[Fazal]

Originally posted by Tintin
I got 20

See the brighter side. May be you are the only one who is able/capable to self-evaluate without any bias and admit it (the real score) to the public.

[oracle]

i got 32.

I think the mods should be left out of the test or creat e a test for them?

... cause i did'nt know how to answer:

"whether i got into trouble with other members? and "how many personal contacts with members?".

Anyway, i got 26..

[bdmoderator]

31 from me. I am nearly there

[ZunaidH]

The point of creating the thread about favourite posters was not to create a popularity contest. I just wanted to share that I have come to know some great people in/through this site.

So those of you who are contemplating a hatemail, or those who have already sent one , I hope that explains.

[RazabQ]

39 for me ... I get into trouble with a lot of people