Ideal Starting XI

[Gowza]

Originally Posted by Rana Melb
Aber arzzak..omg!!!

Dropping Shabbir would be a great mistake. He shld be in for NAsir.

Why not have both? Nasir is still more useful than a number of players in the squad and sabbir has done ok.

[hbk619]

bd lineup:

tamim(job:rotating strike..give as much strike to anamul)
anamul(job:attacking batting from the fast ball)
shamsur(job:double attacking)
mominul(job:if the openers fail....he should go for taking singles...then build up his innings..or if he comes in middle overs...should play his natural game )
shakib(perfect batsman to come in middle overs)
mushfique( perfect batsman to come in middle overs)
sabbir(attacking batting right from the word go in slog overs)
Zia(attacking batting from slog overs to end....wanna see some raining sixes from him)
Riyad(jodi 8 batsman kisu na korte pare..taile uni kisu kore dekhailo...useful guy in bowling..and better choice than razzak)
Mashrafee/Gazi (if it's a spinning track...go for gazi....
Al-Amin/Mashrafe

[Rana Melb]

Originally Posted by hbk619
bd lineup:

tamim(job:rotating strike..give as much strike to anamul)
anamul(job:attacking batting from the fast ball)
shamsur(job:double attacking)
mominul(job:if the openers fail....he should go for taking singles...then build up his innings..or if he comes in middle overs...should play his natural game )
shakib(perfect batsman to come in middle overs)
mushfique( perfect batsman to come in middle overs)
sabbir(attacking batting right from the word go in slog overs)
Zia(attacking batting from slog overs to end....wanna see some raining sixes from him)
Riyad(jodi 8 batsman kisu na korte pare..taile uni kisu kore dekhailo...useful guy in bowling..and better choice than razzak)
Mashrafee/Gazi (if it's a spinning track...go for gazi....
Al-Amin/Mashrafe

Bro, spinners r missing here

[hbk619]

Originally Posted by Rana Melb
Bro, spinners r missing here

shakib,riyad,gazi,mominul,sabbir...apner aro spinner lagbo????

[Fazal]

It's pointless to try to twick and come up with the ideal starting 11. We have some basic fundamental problem in the team, that need to be addressed first. And that is: we need new leadership in the team. Captain and/or Coach need to go. Ideally both, but atleast one need to go. It's not working... the team is dis-functional. Not the coach or the cpatian is making the proper adjustments to make this team a workable one.

Roles are not defined, resources are not used properly, the fielding collectively is going from "average" to "bad" to "ugly".... and nothing is being done to address that. It's hard to beleive that few years back we were pretty decent fielding team.

Wicket keeping is very inconsistent and far lower than "below par", field placing is not consistent with the bowling, and dropping catches and mis-fielding are just demoralizing our average bowlers.

Nobody knows what is expected out of each player, and how they will be made accountable. The punishment is inconsistent and role is not clear to the players.

Just change the coach and the cpatain and you will see, the same core group of players will produce different performance.

So until we get a new management, there is no point wasting time in trying to get ideal team. All will falter under this management.

[naim519]

^ Definitely obviously probably!!!

We are back to our old days...

[Nafi]

I think its clear mominul cant play this format.

[reyme]

I agree with Fazal wholeheartedly...

[Rinathq]

Originally Posted by Fazal
Its pointless to try to twick and come up with ideal starting 11. We have some basic fundamental problem in the team, that need to eb addressed first. And that is we need new leadership in the team. Captain and/or Coach need to go. Ideally both, but atleast one need to go. Its not working... the team is disfunctional. Not the coach or the cpatian is making the proper adjustments to make this team a workable one.

Roles are not defined, resources are not used properly, the fielding collectively is going from average to bad to ugly.... and nothing is being done to address that. Its hard to beleive that few years back we were pretty decent fieling team.

Wicket keeping is very inconsistent and far below par, field placing is not consistent with the bowling, and dropping catches and mis fielding is making is just demoralizing our average bowlers.

No body knows what is expected out of each player, and how they will be made accountable. The punishment is inconsistent and role is not clear to the players.

Just change the coach and the cpatain and you will see, the sma ecore group of players will produce different performance.

So until we get a new management, there is no point wasting time in trying to get ideal team. All will falter under this management.

thank you!

[reyme]

We need better coaching staff in all 3 areas if we want to stop this backward plunge...no point keep shuffling starting 11. As Fazal said nothing is working under this leadership....

[munnabhai]

Terrible captaincy, we need to change the captain. If he brought in Shakib earlier he could have got rid of Smith. Also not to mention the extras give by our bowler 19, terrible keeping also add an extra 20 given by our misfields. That's 39 runs, the target would have been 132. Mushy lacks a brain.

Mushy can stay as a batsman solely but I think Anamul should keep. He was quite bad on the field as well. On what basis is Shamsur warming the bench and Riyadh gets a nod to play?

The players lack the passion to play for Bangladesh.

My starting 11.

Shamsur
Anamul
Riyadh - He won't get the chop and we all know it (better to get rid of him in the first few overs)
Tamim Iqbal
Mushfiqur Rahim
Shakib al Hasan
Nasir Hossain (out of form Nasir > Shabbir in form)
Zia ur Rahman
Mashrafee
Gazi
Al Amin