Bangladesh vs Tony Hill

[MohammedC]

Can Bangladesh win against Tony Hill ?

Could Dean Du Plessis make a better umpire in place of Hills ?

Is ICC deaf ?

Who is sponsoring Hills ? Geoffrey Boycotts mother in law ?

What is your thought ?

[Rabz]

Can we compile one and send it to ICC Review Committee ?

Ok, the third one is an iffy, too close to call, you can understand that one.
But what about the first two ?
Put it next to Tamim and Ash's out in the 2nd innings, you would have to wonder why !!

[Vepu]

3rd one not conclusive enough even after so many replies. benifit of doubt goes to batsman. nots sure about 2nd decision as i can see the leg stump and hit on full but ball was angling down + gazi was turning the ball sharply. 1st one was plumb but let me tell you bd had few plumb ones not given in the first innings. tamim ash was given out wrongly so was shingi and chakava. now you can start calculating who was affected more but i think umpires are not just good enough or they are having a really bad test. nothing to do with being anti-bangladesh

[nadim 98]

Khela kobe? Lords e naki? Day night?

Posted via BC Mobile Edition (Opera Mobile)

[simon]

borda ekta compilation kore FB e choraya den kindly.

Wisdom of Tony Hill marka ekta page lagbe mone hochchey

[PoorFan]

BCB definitely should take him to ICC, And after the series I want BD management to take on him in Zimbo, make buzz on his 'lack of his umpiring skill'.

[PoorFan]

Each series BD should compile umpire decisions and make sure ICC and cricket world have a notice, it should be done as strategy and Banglacricket could a better option than BCB, since as a part of body of ICC, BCB cant go whining every time umpire making wrong decisions against BD.

[ahnaf]

Bhais,Tony hill ki ODI teo umpiring korbe? Tahole to amra shesh bhais!

Posted via BC Mobile Edition (Opera Mobile)

[BengaliPagol]

Someone compil it together and make a funny video out of it.

[Rubu]

Off all the decisions, the effiest of the effy is the decision to end the play early on 4th day without giving mushy a chance to bowl spinners only. As if they have decided to punish him for the excessive appealing just a few overs ago, even though they have already warned him.

[King13]

Was he not fair to both teams? I mean some of wickets of zim batsmen was poor decision, he has been equal, hopefully bcb gets drs soon

[shuziburo]

Originally Posted by PoorFan
Each series BD should compile umpire decisions and make sure ICC and cricket world have a notice, it should be done as strategy and Banglacricket could a better option than BCB, since as a part of body of ICC, BCB cant go whining every time umpire making wrong decisions against BD.

FB can be a great outlet for this. Whether someone at ICC will hear of it from FB is another question.

[shuziburo]

Originally Posted by Rubu
Off all the decisions, the effiest of the effy is the decision to end the play early on 4th day without giving mushy a chance to bowl spinners only. As if they have decided to punish him for the excessive appealing just a few overs ago, even though they have already warned him.

They were extremely inconsistent as well. They did not do this on days 1 - 3. They also did not come down hard on ZIM when they also were appealing excessively at some points.

[shuziburo]

All three should have been out, but 1 and 2 were no-doubters. Truly incompetent officiating.

[Dilscoop]

Those 3 aren't blunders. You have to add Tamim's and Jahurul's 2x decisions.

[shakibrulz]

Originally Posted by Dilscoop
Those 3 aren't blunders. You have to add Tamim's and Jahurul's 2x decisions.

+1. All three of them aren't howlers. Tamim, Jahurul, and also Ash's IMO. Horrible ones those.

Mo, you could do a compilation of the howlers right?

[BD_TigerZ]

Worst part is he most likely gets paid much more than most of us..

[akabir77]

ICC has wasted its money spending behind tony hill instead they should have spent it on nadir shah...

[Dilscoop]

No point in sending this to ICC. I know what their answer will be. "Get DRS, vote DRS."

[reyme]

These are not incompetence or wrong decisions, these are just simply biased and disgraceful! Try doing these against India, BCCI will end his career! Too bad BCB is too busy addressing this critical issue!

Thanks Mohammed Bhai for the timely thread.

[MohammedC]

Originally Posted by reyme
These are not incompetence or wrong decisions, these are just simply biased and disgraceful! Try doing these against India, BCCI will end his career! Too bad BCB is too busy addressing this critical issue!

Thanks Mohammed Bhai for the timely thread.

But the thing is he will adapt for the Indians fearing his career. He looks like dodgy character.

Billy Bowden was umpiring the first match but we cant even remember him because he is an honest umpire. I know in the past Billy has made errors but he is not biased towards a team.

To err is human. But what Tony Hill was doing was unfair. Ok let say Tony was fair then you must question can he handle high pressure match if not he should be given the red card like Asoka.

[Dilscoop]

There is a good chance that he's just bad. Otherwise he wouldn't risk his job like that. Doing well in these low profile games will open things up for him. So he'd stabbing himself too not just us.

As for tue umps going against us against the top teams is not biased but human nature to be on the good side of tough guys.

[ReZ_1]

I am still confused whether he is deliberate or toooo smart to respond to the situation.

[BengaliPagol]

maybe he is []

[nahaz]

Originally Posted by BengaliPagol
maybe he is []

This is a serious allegation.'why don't you email the ICC? Ask them if their chosen elite umpires can really be thus unskilled or whether tony hill is []?