Who's Worse?

[Zeeshan]

I love when Democrats become Republicans and vice versa!!!

I was the BIGGEST BACKER of Shakib-Tamim after their controversy. Hehe I remember Sohel bhai and others were against their attitude problem. As much as I didn't support battu-da's captaincy, over the years, he made me a Believer (No....not! Belieber!)

1. Asia Cup finals
2. West Indies 61
3. West Indies T20
4. Yesterday

Come'on what else y'all want as a proof that he is the right man for job. Good leader doesn't necessarily have to be a star athlete. It helps but he is EXTREMELY PROACTIVE on the field. Ash was a bit like that.

But, I am afraid it'd affect Tamasha's game performance if either are made captain.

Mushy 2013!!

[M.H.Rubel]

Originally Posted by Eshen
Shakib failed to hold the team together and thoroughly deserved to lose captaincy after the WC. Don't see any reason to go back to him as the captain. Tamim certainly doesn't have the levelheadedness that required of a captain either.

As of now, Mushfiq is doing fine.

Very simple logical thinking. Agreed 100%.
A person who can not unite a team how can we think making him captain?

[BengaliPagol]

Originally Posted by Eshen
Shakib is our hardest working cricketer.

Actually Shakib is the most laziest out of anyone in the team. Off field, in training he is the laziest. On the field he is energetic.

[cricheart]

I remember Shakib's comment on whether he misses his captaincy role. In answer he said, "Nah, not at all, just miss the suite service in hotel"

[Roey Haque]

Originally Posted by Zeeshan
I love when Democrats become Republicans and vice versa!!!

I was the BIGGEST BACKER of Shakib-Tamim after their controversy. Hehe I remember Sohel bhai and others were against their attitude problem. As much as I didn't support battu-da's captaincy, over the years, he made me a Believer (No....not! Belieber!)

1. Asia Cup finals
2. West Indies 61
3. West Indies T20
4. Yesterday

Come'on what else y'all want as a proof that he is the right man for job. Good leader doesn't necessarily have to be a star athlete. It helps but he is EXTREMELY PROACTIVE on the field. Ash was a bit like that.

But, I am afraid it'd affect Tamasha's game performance if either are made captain.

Mushy 2013!!

One merits a place in the team first, before being a captain. You are gonna tell me Mushy isn't the worst keeper in the international stage? I don't support having two keepers in the team. Make Anamul the keeper, and give chances to better quality batsmen like Mominul in place of Mushfiq. For a team like Bd, having those 3 or 4 excellent players is more important than fretting about the captaincy.

Btw, I voted Bashar. Mushfiq's captaincy might not be decent, but Bashar's was downright terrifying!

[Zeeshan]

Originally Posted by Roey Haque

Btw, I voted Bashar. Mushfiq's captaincy might not be decent, but Bashar's was downright terrifying!

bashar goenda manush...onake onar moton thakte din... koi feluda jokon du tin din kotha na bole thake, tokhon to tanke kichu bola hoy na?

[Zunaid]

I am getting tired of the interminable posts here trying to determining who is worse than whom. Why are we so negative? Granted, we fans have the right to criticize the failings as WE are their clients but we seem too eager to find fault at every turn and pick every nit we can. I am so tired of all the negativity.

[al Furqaan]

Im not sure Mushy is a terrible captain. Certainly not worse than HB... Then again HB's team would only win on the back of an AshraEid. Shakib might be a better tactician. But re ords wise MR has won 4/11 ODIs v G8 sides and we should have won 3 more! That being said shakib is still prolly the better choice.

[NoName]

Don't like Mushy's captaincy, but I never followed BD pre-07 WC so I don't know how effective or smart Bashar was as a captain. Sure we lost every single game (except 05 Zim series, and the odd ODIs), but our only decent players were Bashar, Rafique and Ash (his Eid days were more frequent att).