Shakib and Shahadat fined - Page 2

Kabir · #1 July 14, 2009, 12:22 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Rabz
But who cares, we won!

Jar taka gese, she e bujhbe...

Fazal · #2 July 14, 2009, 01:01 PM

How about the umpires? Shouldn’t they be also disciplined?

Akib · #3 July 14, 2009, 12:24 PM

Imagine all the anti-ashoka or anti-umpiring or anti-ash threads there would have been if we lost..... Doubt the servers could handle it.

abc70 · #4 July 14, 2009, 12:29 PM

F******* Asoka De Silva is very lucky that we won otherwise I would have shoot him right back of his head...

this guy don't even no what is plumb in cricket.Idiot.

billah · #5 July 14, 2009, 03:56 PM

We need to see more of these fines after every match, regularly.

In the past, we've seen genuine run outs not appealed. This goes to show that our coaches are training the players right. They must appeal, and everyone should appeal together. Our demure attitude about appealing had cost us dearly in the past. This helps keep the umps like Ashoka on their toes. Very much needed.

The Aussies and the Indians are happy to forgo part of match fees, by delaying the over rates to take away the momentum from the opponents (captain is fined, in this case). This is just appealing. Even with the appealing, I'd say at least 3 genuine lbw went against us.

I'm very happy to see that finally these guys are appealing hard. Keep it up.

Sauron · #6 July 14, 2009, 10:03 PM

I hope they accept 10% penalty as a given and more team members start appealing more vociferously. In the end, even if one decision turns around because of the extra strong appeal - it's worth it

manali · #7 July 14, 2009, 10:06 PM

You guys won the match...who cares abt the fine.

cricket_king · #8 July 14, 2009, 10:23 PM

Man that's the kind of stuff that India does. Really looks bad on our behalf. Idiots. Hopefully they've learnt their lesson.

Sauron · #9 July 14, 2009, 10:27 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by cricket_king
Man that's the kind of stuff that India does. Really looks bad on our behalf. Idiots. Hopefully they've learnt their lesson.

As long as they don't cheat, a win is a win. There is no lesson to learn here, other than - be willing to lose part of your match fee if it helps the team hold the edge.

You must be a tree-hugging tofu eater. All red meat eaters would support this behavior, I'd think

RazabQ · #10 July 14, 2009, 10:36 PM

Win on Test and all sorts of people come out of hibernation. First it was Shubho, now Sauron

Foozy · #11 July 15, 2009, 01:01 AM

This is pathetic considering all the wrong umpiring. BCB should talk to ICC about this, and get a shoka out of our games for good. This man is a real disgrace to cricket.

Antora · #12 July 15, 2009, 01:23 AM

Just like a lot of you, I too am wondering how Mushy got away with it!

Baundule · #13 July 15, 2009, 01:36 AM

It is no problem if Ponting rushes to the umpire with the ball in his palm appealing for a catch with a killer look in his eyes. It is no problem, if England wastes time for no visible reason, clearly for saving the match. All dirty play for them is fine; but as a Bangladeshi, we can just appeal saying 'How's that', not 'Haaaaaaauuuuuuuz thaaaaaaaaat'

ICC sucks!

Gowza · #14 July 15, 2009, 01:39 AM

india and sri lanka do the same thing when they appeal, if not worse.

cricadda · #15 July 15, 2009, 01:55 AM

when ashoka made us lose against pakistan in multan test, he did not get fined. so why saqib and shahadat got fined?? beacause they are doing there job??? its not make any sence...

BANFAN · #16 July 15, 2009, 02:58 AM

Shahadat I guess for not leaving the crease after calling out in first innings. Shakib I don't know why? May be for the team?

Infact WI was appealing much more than us, sometimes even ball going quiet away from the bat. BD did at the last leg of the 4th innings which was very logical. Every one does that in the 4th inings situations like this. Even in Ashes last day, Ausies were doing the same. You know it's easy to do it agains BD.

Murad · #17 July 15, 2009, 09:16 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by BANFAN
Shahadat I guess for not leaving the crease after calling out in first innings. Shakib I don't know why? May be for the team?

Infact WI was appealing much more than us, sometimes even ball going quiet away from the bat. BD did at the last leg of the 4th innings which was very logical. Every one does that in the 4th inings situations like this. Even in Ashes last day, Ausies were doing the same. You know it's easy to do it agains BD.

One of the appeal from Shahadat was very long and he got mad when it was not given by Ashoka as it was plumb.

I liked it when Shahadat did it. Ashoka needs some angry mens to cure his blindness!

auntu · #18 July 16, 2009, 03:08 AM

^^^Shahadat's LBW appeal in the 2nd innings against the opener where the batsman was run out by Rokib. That was OUT no doubt.

Naimul_Hd · #19 July 16, 2009, 08:50 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by auntu
^^^Shahadat's LBW appeal in the 2nd innings against the opener where the batsman was run out by Rokib. That was OUT no doubt.

yep...surely ! that batsman was shocked not to be given out by the umpire...and tht eventually got him run out. ! so i guess sometimes its better not to give plumb LBW to make batsman jolt ! LOL

WIFAN · #20 July 16, 2009, 11:25 AM

I think there was some slight over appealing from the Tigers in the 4th innings. As someone pointed out, the wicket keeper was the worst offender and he didn't even get a warning.

I think some common sense should have been shown by the match referee. A quiet word with the Bangladesh team management would have been fine. It was a huge opportunity to win only their 2nd test, of course they were going to be excited. I have seen far worse over-appealing from other teams in similar circumstances go unpunished.