No more Mushfiqur Rahim please... - Page 4

akabir77 · #76 February 26, 2008, 03:13 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by zainab
.

--------------------------------------------------------------------------------

Banglacricket is featured here as saying that fans here wants him out. Why is it that they did not pick up on the blatant fact that fans wants Habibul Bashar out also, who IMO is having a free ride by occupying a seat as a privileged spectator.

At least Mushy does some work behind the stumps.

Please post the source...

Also I agree i think Mushi is our second head ache here. The first one you nailed it...

What the hell are the reporters doing here trying to work for Pilot?

akabir77 · #77 February 26, 2008, 03:15 PM

the thread opener looks like used us to get his article and the backup for pilot

zainab · #78 February 26, 2008, 03:20 PM

Sorry, I did not mention, but it is NEW AGE SPORTS based in BD. I read it on their website and was quite surprised that they mentioned Banglacricket forum.

Also. on the forum, there has been a lot of talk about everyone wanting Bashar dropped, but that was not mentioned at all, in fact no one asked Siddons. I wpuld have been happy to hear his response.

ammark · #79 February 26, 2008, 03:21 PM

Seems like a dailystar* quote. Wow talk about selective quoting!! Very Disappointed.

*okay, sorry my bad... newage it is then. But still VERY shoddy journalism. I thought Sham is working for them now too!

rah · #80 February 26, 2008, 03:31 PM

we cannot complain on mushfiques batting atm, how can we expect him to perfrom if he comes in at to bat at 8:S he should be tested up the order and have more innings experience of being out there in the middle with our top order batsmen

Shaan · #81 February 26, 2008, 03:37 PM

Seems like HABA is getting axed eventually, check this out :http://www.shamokal.com/details.php?nid=90394

zainab · #82 February 26, 2008, 03:45 PM

Cannot read Bangla, Please an overview of a few lines in English. i will be so happy if he got axed and Reza brought in. He is a batsman, bowler and fielder. What is Bashar? to me looks brain dead.

Thanks

MarufH · #83 February 26, 2008, 04:05 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by zainab
Cannot read Bangla, Please an overview of a few lines in English. i will be so happy if he got axed and Reza brought in. He is a batsman, bowler and fielder. What is Bashar? to me looks brain dead.

Thanks

One of the BCB official said they offered Bashar to retire... otherwise he might be axed.... and they are talking about getting another genuine spinner in the team (Razzak) and Rajin to improve batting strength.

*AsifTheManRahman* · #84 February 26, 2008, 04:19 PM

A couple of points regarding the article posted by Zainab:

1) English likhte na parle shalara Banglay likhe na ken? Ke koise eto koshto koira English journalist hoite?

2) The reporter sounds like my nani when she tries to weave a conspiracy theory surrounding her daughters-in-law. If I ever meet the guy in person, dot dot bleep bleep.

3) This just goes to show how banglacricket.com can provide fodder to people with no bloody skills looking at a career at journalism. We talk, they write, and the players read. There's a difference between constructive criticism and absolute bull dung, and if you're nineteen and under performing, it doesn't really help.

*AsifTheManRahman* · #85 February 26, 2008, 04:22 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by rah
we cannot complain on mushfiques batting atm, how can we expect him to perfrom if he comes in at to bat at 8:S he should be tested up the order and have more innings experience of being out there in the middle with our top order batsmen

Bhaiya, this is the main problem. We make him bat at #8 and expect him to play like a #3. All that because our #3, or anyone in the top/middle orders for that matter, didn't do his job.

Chillate chaile chillano jaay, kintu ektu buddhi khatate ajkal onek taka poysha khoroch howe jaay mone hoy.

PS: As myself.

akabir77 · #86 February 26, 2008, 04:26 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Shaan
Seems like HABA is getting axed eventually, check this out :http://www.shamokal.com/details.php?nid=90394

I will believe it when i see it or should i say won't see it!!!!

djnaved · #87 February 26, 2008, 05:07 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by rah
we cannot complain on mushfiques batting atm, how can we expect him to perfrom if he comes in at to bat at 8:S he should be tested up the order and have more innings experience of being out there in the middle with our top order batsmen

bro, it's not only about his batting, also about his keeping. Commentators also said that his arms are too small, and he closes his hand before he tries to catch a ball.

This are basic techniques of being a keeper, and if mushy don't know this things, he should be resigned.

zainab · #88 February 27, 2008, 10:48 AM

In spite of all the talk and criticism about Mushy, Siddons will retain him. How can a wicketkeeper be changed in midstream. Dhiman has no internationl experience and Pilot is out of touch. Who else can they select? better to have someone who can perform at 90% rather than trying a rookie.

The bigger problem is Bashar and bringing in another bowler.

cracky · #89 February 27, 2008, 12:29 PM

come on, any bowler can definitely score more than Bashar, bowling will be the bonus.

Quote:

Originally Posted by zainab
The bigger problem is Bashar and bringing in another bowler.

mshakir56 · #90 February 27, 2008, 01:08 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by cracky
come on, any bowler can definitely score more than Bashar, bowling will be the bonus.

bang on target !

zainab · #91 February 27, 2008, 03:49 PM

The bigger problem is Bashar and bringing in another bowler.

What I meant is dropping Bashar and bringing in another bowler. i also would like to see Reza playing. I feel that he deserves a chance.

Gowza · #92 February 27, 2008, 04:41 PM

i think bashar and rahim are as bigger problems as each other, rahim atm is just as useless if not worse than bashar with the bat rahim has only made 8 more runs than bashar in their last 10 test innings and most of rahim's runs came from that 80 in sri lanka, if you just count their last 9 innings rahim has only made 42 runs at 4.6, bashar in the last 9 innings has made 98 runs at 10.8. so bashar recently has made more than double the runs rahim has. i don't have a problem with changing the keeper if it's going to better the team and at this point i think it will better the team and the reason i'd pick dhiman over pilot is because pilot is about to retire, dhiman could potentially help the team over the long term whereas pilot would be a very short term solution.

djnaved · #93 February 27, 2008, 05:05 PM

vai, ami mushfiqer batting o keeping shomporke onek agea lickhchilam, onekei patta dei nai... r ekhon tara mushfiqer bipokkhe lekhe..

pocha · #94 February 27, 2008, 05:09 PM

Please no Mushy and Haba anymore.Period.

BanCricFan · #95 February 27, 2008, 05:18 PM

Golden Boy will be relieved of his duty only when his 'golden' average becomes a grand '0'!

Its good to show faith and trust in a young player but destroying his career is another thing. JS made a grave error by sticking with Mushy...hope I'm astoundingly wrong though.

auntu · #96 February 27, 2008, 05:22 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by djnaved
vai, ami mushfiqer batting o keeping shomporke onek agea lickhchilam, onekei patta dei nai... r ekhon tara mushfiqer bipokkhe lekhe..

eitai hoi re bhai onner kotha pachal mone hoi, nijer kotha boktobbo mone hoi

Murad · #97 February 27, 2008, 05:41 PM

Mushy er ekhon to jaa chance ache future e valo korar.. ar kichu din pore mone hoi na ta thakbe. 7 number e khelle ki run kora jai na.. not even in double digits? I meant 10/15/20?

Kintu o jodi erokom kore aro kichu match khele then or future e onek shomossa hobe abar team e dhukte..

He needs a break so badly.

akabir77 · #98 February 27, 2008, 05:42 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by djnaved
vai, ami mushfiqer batting o keeping shomporke onek agea lickhchilam, onekei patta dei nai... r ekhon tara mushfiqer bipokkhe lekhe..

Er maney ki? mushfiq was the only person available or in form when we needed to replace pilot. he did well that time didn't he? koi tokhon to dekhi nai aisha boltey bhalo hoisey pilot rey wc they kheley nai, ami bhull bolsi. ekhon or form kharap tai at least ami ekhon bolchi we should give him a rest cause we think about the team not like some one who supports people blindly....

Going or saying against Mushi now doesn't prove that he wasn't a the best option before WC. so stop saying that Mushi inclusion from the very beginning was bad which was not.

*AsifTheManRahman* · #99 February 27, 2008, 05:50 PM

Why do people want to play Dhiman? What has he done to deserve a TEST spot? Sure, he'll probably make it to the test team one day, but now's probably not the right time. Besides, if Siddons says Mushy's glove work is the best that we can ask for at the moment, then he's probably on to something. He's not really your average street side drunkard, after all.

Even if we do replace Mushy with Dhiman, where are we going to play the latter? At #8? And expect him to provide results with the bat when we're down 6 or 7 wickets and the game's literally over? Even the best cannot survive long with tail enders all around them.

pocha · #**100** February 27, 2008, 06:04 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by AsifTheManRahman
Why do people want to play Dhiman? What has he done to deserve a TEST spot? Sure, he'll probably make it to the test team one day, but now's probably not the right time. Besides, if Siddons says Mushy's glove work is the best that we can ask for at the moment, then he's probably on to something. He's not really your average street side drunkard, after all.

Even if we do replace Mushy with Dhiman, where are we going to play the latter? At #8? And expect him to provide results with the bat when we're down 6 or 7 wickets and the game's literally over? Even the best cannot survive long with tail enders all around them.

When someone is recklessly out of form he needs a break. Its good for Mushy if he takes a break and come back strongly. He is young and he can surely come back. I dont know whether Dhiman or Pilot will be the right person, but they cant be any worse at the moment. And we just cant depend on one single WK, we need a pool of good keepers and there is no harm in giving others a chance when the best keeper is terribly out of form for a very long period. If they fail we have nothing to loose but if they succeed we have everything to gain.Period.