Who should replace Shakib in 1st 2 ODIs?

[Saifulsohel]

Who should replace Shak? A spinner, a batsman or an allrounder?

[Naimul_Hd]

I would go for a genuine spinner. We are too full with batsmen and part time all rounders. We need another genuine spinner along side with Sohag and Razzaq !

I say, Arafat Sunny or Saqline Sajib !

[Isnaad]

Originally Posted by Naimul_Hd
I would go for a genuine spinner. We are too full with batsmen and part time all rounders. We need another genuine spinner along side with Sohag and Razzaq !

I say, Arafat Sunny or Saqline Sajib !

Mind you, Sohag Gazi is mediocre with the bat. So, going with 3 specialist bowlers in the form of spinners may easily backfire.

[Nadim]

now, nayeem will replace shak in the XI for sure....


but to replace him in the squad, i would say Mominul Haque

[BANFAN]

We don't need any genuine spinner in ODIs, we needed it for the test side. Bits and pieces all rounders like Naeem, Naseer, Mullah are enough along with 2 pacers and Gazi. I can't see batting in ODI...need a solid batsman in place of Shakb..or may be a batting all rounder....

I'll be happy to see Naeem out of ODI team... Let Alok, Junaid, Mominul... Any two come in... Zia is a must in the ODI side...

[Maysun]

I want Zia. The rest can move up the batting order by a place and we can have Zia for onslaught later in the innings.

[Naimul_Hd]

Originally Posted by BANFAN
We don't need any genuine spinner in ODIs, we needed it for the test side. Bits and pieces all rounders like Naeem, Naseer, Mullah are enough along with 2 pacers and Gazi. I can't see batting in ODI...need a solid batsman in place of Shakb..or may be a batting all rounder....

I'll be happy to see Naeem out of ODI team... Let Alok, Junaid, Mominul... Any two come in... Zia is a must in the ODI side...

How did i forget Zia !!

I agree with you.

[MyRoom]

That's why you should never prepare such lifeless Cricket pitches because these things (injuries) will happen. ODIs were our best chance of winning now I pretty much doubt it.

[Gowza]

shuvagata bowls a bit of spin doesn't he? possibly him if you want someone who can bat but spin a bit as well. otherwise a genuine spinner or mominul.

[MohammedC]

Someone please start a "Your XI for ODI" thread

[BANFAN]

Originally Posted by MohammedC
Someone please start a "Your XI for ODI" thread

It's here : Your Team.

[fuadomar]

Zia or Mominul.

[deshimon]

I prefer Zia. Zia should be in the first squad. I don't know why selectors didn't take him. But now he is must.

[MyRoom]

Wrong question! because you can't replace Shakib

[MyRoom]

Naeem was a mistake!, if the pitch is still flat then go with 3 seamers like Asia Cup - Mashrafe, Rubel and yes Abul (let's just see) or if the pitch is going to offer turn then 2 seamers and 3 specialist spinners no part-timers like Naeem. My 3 spinners will be Razzak, Sunny and Gazi so it depends what the pitch is like. This also means that Tamim needs to seriously perform which I pretty much doubt.

[WarWolf]

Does it matter at all?

As long as we have the selectors in charge who believe in the same team for test, ODI and T20, I don't see any meaning in wasting my words.

[sharup]

Zia is not for ODI. Those miss-and-hit-wicket shots are only for t20 batting at 7/8. We need to prep him for ODI. I don't think he's ready for ODI jelly.

[KaaL-PurusH]

I dont see any better option than Akram Khan himself. He is an all rounder too

[simon]

rokter bodole rokto, Sakib er bodole Shakib

[Crisis]

Sadly, there is no replacement for Shakib. There is not a single person in the team who is an all-rounder of his calibre

[Crisis]

And, no Nazmul again... sigh!

[oronnya]

Bring back Ash. He definitely will do a much better job than this faltu Shakib.

[Rabz]

Originally Posted by simon


rokter bodole rokto, Sakib er bodole Shakib

Perfect find.

[abu2abu]

Enamul haque junior...

[M.H.Rubel]

Originally Posted by simon


rokter bodole rokto, Sakib er bodole Shakib

L O L. Great find.