Shakib blames board for lack of review system

[Imtiazk]

By the way, amongst all this Sakib-praising, I did not like his criticism of Razzak. He should not have done this in public. Such things should be done within the dressing room. Today Razzak, tomorrow whom ?

This is not good man management. You will never see Alex Ferguson or Wenger ever criticise their players in the media. Inside the dressing room, it might be a different matter.

[Neel Here]

Originally Posted by AsifTheManRahman
So they fined Siddons: http://www.cricinfo.com/bdeshveng201...ry/453188.html

Now who will fine the umpires?

quis ipsodiet ipsos custodes ? this system is broken down. either you have to be pedigreed like the old masters, eng, aus or nz or you have to have muscle power like BCCI (and even that doesn't save India most of the time), nothing else works. pathetic.

[BD-Shardul]

Originally Posted by Imtiazk
By the way, amongst all this Sakib-praising, I did not like his criticism of Razzak. He should not have done this in public. Such things should be done within the dressing room. Today Razzak, tomorrow whom ?

This is not good man management. You will never see Alex Ferguson or Wenger ever criticise their players in the media. Inside the dressing room, it might be a different matter.

That was the right thing. The captain reserves the right to express his frustration if a man under his command fails to deliver according to expectation. If Dhoni can warn Tendulkar publicly for not performing, I don't see any reason why Shakib cannot criticize Raz who lost focus every over and conceded a boundary.

[Imtiazk]

Originally Posted by BD-Shardul
That was the right thing. The captain reserves the right to express his frustration if a man under his command fails to deliver according to expectation. If Dhoni can warn Tendulkar publicly for not performing, I don't see any reason why Shakib cannot criticize Raz who lost focus every over and conceded a boundary.

So who will criticise Shakib for repeatedly executing that horrible slog-sweep ?

[BD-Shardul]

Originally Posted by Imtiazk
So who will criticise Shakib for repeatedly executing that horrible slog-sweep ?

লোটাইচ্চা

[Peace]

Originally Posted by BD-Shardul
লোটাইচ্চা

so why loota was wrong and shakib is right for the same conduct?

[WarWolf]

Originally Posted by peace
so why loota was wrong and shakib is right for the same conduct?

কারন লোইচ্চা আগে থেকেই তেলো মাথায় তেল ঢালার দায়ে আভিযুক্ত। কিন্তু সাকিব তা না।

[Peace]

Originally Posted by WarWolf
কারন লোইচ্চা আগে থেকেই তেলো মাথায় তেল ঢালার দায়ে আভিযুক্ত। কিন্তু সাকিব তা না।

One issue at a time. The issue here is criticism of subordinate personnel, publicly.

If Shakib was upset of lotus’s comment that BD players play irresponsibly, similarly, Razzak has right to be upset although both lotus and Shakib were right in their judgement.

We need to remember-
"Treat others, the way you want to be treated"

[Bond]

Originally Posted by Imtiazk
By the way, amongst all this Sakib-praising, I did not like his criticism of Razzak. He should not have done this in public. Such things should be done within the dressing room. Today Razzak, tomorrow whom ?

This is not good man management. You will never see Alex Ferguson or Wenger ever criticise their players in the media. Inside the dressing room, it might be a different matter.

he replies openly, kicks u in the forehead and makes u bleed.