Ashraful listed as 1 of the worst test batsmen

[abz..+]

Originally Posted by rashed411
bwahahaha idk if i should laugh or cry...

you should laugh

[BANFAN]

Too much experiment with him and trying to change his batting style completely against his natural abilities has hindered his improvement to a great extent. Hope he realizes his own strengths and plays to his strengths.

[Tiger444]

Very nicely put beamer...of course Ashrafuls average is weak but he still cannot be dropped as on a given day he can take over a match..

[al Furqaan]

ash is actually a year older than his cricinfo "official" age...meaning he was 18 when he hit that ton against SL, and so he wasn't really the youngest ever centurion.

but he isn't 2-3 years older than his purported age. i suspect guys like nafees iqbal, SN, rajib, and possibly tamim too are 2-3 years older than their official ages.

[Zeeshan]

it's impolite to ask a bangladeshi cricketer's age.

[CholCholBD]

Originally Posted by Spitfire_x86
For the n-th time, only a very naive person will believe in the official age of a Bangladeshi sportsman.

Many tailenders who can bat would be better choice for a specialist batsman's slot than Ashraful.

Yes sir I am not naive. If it pleases u, u can add 3-4 years to his age, it still doesnt change how much he has accomplished in his short career.

So u are willing to put ur money where your mouth is about tailenders replacing Ashraful or were you just trying to be oversmart?

[Rifat]

Originally Posted by Beamer
Some people just never fullfil their potential. Cricketing history is littered with that. Batting is a mindset. I would argue that it is 60% skill and 40% mental toughness. In our case, mentally tough batsmen are almost non-existent, and those who had some degree of mental toughness, unluckily were not technically sufficient. Ash-Alok-Aftab etc had enough skill set to be good intl. players, yut mentally impotent, on the other end of the spectrum, we had likes of JO- Rajin, who had the will to fight, but technically not solvent! So, what do we do? We do what we have to do. That is identify and persist with players that have the technical skill and 'hoping' that by playing in different situations, they will eventually muster mental strength. Along the way, some one like Sakib will pop up who combines both aspects of the game more efficiently.

In case of Ashraful, it is hard to plead for his case. Stats do not lie. His pitiful avg is not reflective of his skills. But, be mindful, that we are Bangladesh, not Australia or India, and we certainly don't have the luxury of dropping him. Players like Yuvraj Singh had to wait to get a crack in the test line-up because they could afford to so. Unfortunately, as of yet, there is nobody waiting in the ranks to supplant him. Detractors would say, how do we know? how would we know until and unless he is dropped? If we go that route, the probabilities are, we have to keep bringing in younger players. Then, we would cry that they have been brought in too early, if they fail in the transition. It is a delicate situation. Our domestic long version is so poor that replacement player from that pool will always have a question mark. Our pipeline will continue to be from the U-19 level as they come from good structure, coaching and selected from young 'talent' pool. It will be an ongoing process for next five-six years, until youngsters become matured, and Ash will hit thirty something, then he will start to fade away eventually.

So, the tragedy continues. He will retire one day with about eight test hundreds with below 30 avg. It is mostly his fault and he will go unpunished because of the generational period he is in. He can't be dropped. He is probably the only batsman in our ranks that the opposition seriously game-plans ( Bashar previously ). Mentally he is so weak that he can't overcome it by playing honest cricket. Playing for Bangladesh is not easy either. It is much easier to avg 40. when you are sorrounded by avg 50 players all around. Trust me on that. Setting the obvious aside, on talent alone, he should avg on mid -thirties, if not 40's. That will not only boost his image, by averaging higher, he will also increase partnerships runs, which will boost others individual avg. Prayers maybe?

Beamer, thank you for justifying my case in preaching to BanglaCricket Folk Islam is indeed a very powerful tool, when utilized to its true potential, the wealth of Allah is limitless, the beauty of it is, it increases without any limit. but are we thankful enough to handle it?? or (occasionally like myself) will we indulge in "the moment"

in my case, strike a balance between the two! your life is all set

Brilliant post btw

yes, poorfan, your request is granted! i will stop "preaching"

[Tigers_eye]

Woohoo!! Alok made #1 (reading the article).

[Ajfar]

hey atleast he made the list ok..

[BANFAN]

I couldn't understand the thread heading, how Ash is Number 1? From any angle it doesn't look so.
It is a BS article, while he left out many Indian players like Mongia & others quoting they are specialist WK/All rounder. How the hell one of our pure bowler is in that list? More over the cut off line & the parameters are suitable to prove that Indians aren't crap. Pure BS.

[Fazal]

Ha ha Ha....

When Fazal says, nobody gives attention,

When Ananth Narayanan says, it becomes a big issue.

What Ananth says should be no surprise to anyone who follows Bangladesh cricket, unless you are madly love with Ash and blinded by his dazzling look (whatever it is).

And trying compare Ash with Dilshan and Shewag ? How many times I have to tell you, he is at best the fake version of Afridi.

So to survive in the national team, he need to refine his bolwing and play at #8 slot. Thats the best role he can play for bangladesh right now.

[Umar]

Originally Posted by rifat
excellent thread. this is a wake up call for Ashraful...i wonder how many times does this lad really need to wake up

Na ghumaia ..ghumanor van korle wake up joto bar e koruk na keno...it won't make any difference

[Umar]

ALok Kapali
Hannan sharkar
Aminul Islam
Aftab Ahmed
JO
Ashrafool
Al Shahriar

Look at JO (born to be test player), Ash, Aftab and Kapali (there are all High quality players for BD standard).

As much delight these players brought to our nation...they balances it up with the same amount of embarrassemed. Sad news indeed. even after their retirement !

[BanCricFan]

Well, there is only one Ashraful!

[Ashfaq]

Originally Posted by fazal
ha ha ha....

When fazal says, nobody gives attention,

when ananth narayanan says, it becomes a big issue.

What ananth says should be no surprise to anyone who follows bangladesh cricket, unless you are madly love with ash and blinded by his dazzling look (whatever it is).

And trying compare ash with dilshan and shewag ? How many times i have to tell you, he is at best the fake version of afridi.

So to survive in the national team, he need to refine his bolwing and play at #8 slot. Thats the best role he can play for bangladesh right now.

ফজল ভাই, কাংগালের কথা বাসী হইলে ফলে......

[auntu]

হাতী ঘোড়া গেলো তল আনন্দ বলে কত জল...

[Ashfaq]

Ironic that a very mediocre player like Ash will occupy this much attention of Bangladeshi cricket fans. The day we can Ignore him and pay more attention to his cricket will be a turning point. For that to happen, we need some better performers than Ash in the team and bid him sionara for a long time.

[Abirz]

Hahaha well the more matches he plays the more the average goes down.The team should just rest him or he should just retire...will save him some remaining dignity, since we all know,that average isnt going up and ashraful isnt improving ****!
It's not a bad patch in ashraful's career anymore like most of you are hoping,its something permanent in his game... his cricket fundamentals have all got messed up.
It's very sad and dissapointing but the only way i see for him is to start training basic cricket again,like how to hold a bat and basic stance, just like beginners do in cricket.

[Tiger444]

I have been very proud of Ashraful's accomplishments but unfortunately he has not been able 2 do it on a consistent basis...the good thing is that b4 we used 2 always depend on Ashraful 2 win games 4 us which we all kno he cant do regularly and now we have a more consistent match winner in the making w/ Shakib and another very consistent player in Rokibul who is a potential match winner 4 us as well..this will put less pressure on Ashraful and we should take advantage of having Rokibul and Shakib being responsible batsmen and drop Ashraful down and play his natural aggressive style..

[LateCut]

Do we need another thread to point out that Ashrafoul stinks? In my opinion as well as many cricket experts that he is not a batsman or alteast not a top order one. If had my way I would sack him but keep him in the team. If he continues to fail he then should be assigned to A-team where he would have to prove himself to get back to the senior team. Otherwise, we should just thank for the memory and wave good bye or good riddance.

[FagunerAgun]

Khek Khek Khek, another sad day for his supporters.
It shows how dumb and incompetent is BCB and how silly is their petty, partisan politics.

[CholCholBD]

Originally Posted by Fazal
And trying compare Ash with Dilshan and Shewag ? How many times I have to tell you, he is at best the fake version of Afridi.

So to survive in the national team, he need to refine his bolwing and play at #8 slot. Thats the best role he can play for bangladesh right now.

Bhai apni kun dokaner aloo khan ektu bolen please? Amio shei dokanei aloo khabo ajke theke promise

[karimjay.]

there is no point in us looking at these figures and discussing.

the people who need to see it (ashraful and co) are oblivious. i bet they're all lying in a hut somewhere having their afternoon nap.