Grading the players after the SLan test series (2017)

Tigers_eye · #1 March 19, 2017, 08:23 AM

This is totally mine. Make your own and post it if you don't like it.

In the past, mostly I have criticized the teams, captains, coaches, mgmts, fans only for the love of the game. Knowing we could have done better. That being said...

Captain Mushfiq: Whatever the short comings are, you have led us to a series draw at a hostile environment after losing the tosses. Your 2nd innings 6th wicket stand with Shakib of 92 was crucial for this match. 5 dismissals and remaining notout over shadows all the faults. 193 runs with an average of 64 only second to Chandimal. Congratulations. A.

VC Tamim: Player of the match award says it all. That 49 lbw had a good ending I must say. 200+ runs in 4 innings. He is our Warner. He sets the tone. A

Shakib Al Hasan: A. Player of the series. Determination. Loved you for a thousand years; will love you for a thousand more.

Sarkar: He came, he saw, he took it to them. Future is bright. What a fielder!! A

Fizzzzzzzzzzzzzz: Stay healthy, serve the nation. We are already in debt to you. A.

Mizzzzzzzzzzzz: Future captain. 10 wickets @35 average and 31 average with the bat. A

Mosaddek: (Sohel bhai, ore dak nam ki? - miss you man) Be patient and good things happen to those who remain patient. A

Taijul: Under rated dark horse. A

Liton: Showed us what we were missing. Pray get well soon. A

Roy: Celebrate as there is no tomorrow. Well done. A.

Sabbir: Up / down the order, doesn't matter; 40 per innings. Not bad. Fielding outstanding. A

Imrul: In / Out. New role and everything. Duck and everything. A. (this is reward you deserved for NZ series. Bhulini amra)

Taskin: Unlucky with so many catches dropped. Focus on the next assignment. A.

Mahmudullah/Mominul: Part of the team. Behind the closed doors your encouragements count. A.

Zeeshan · #2 March 19, 2017, 08:24 AM

Weather fantasy?

Zeeshan · #3 March 19, 2017, 08:26 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Tigers_eye
This is totally mine. Make your own and post it if you don't like it.

I have criticized the teams, captains, coaches, mgmts, fans only for the love of the game. Knowing we could have done better. That being said...

Captain Mushfiq: Whatever the short comings are, you have led us to a series draw at a hostile environment after losing the tosses. Your 2nd innings 6th wicket stand with Shakib of 92 was crucial for this match. 5 dismissals and remaining notout over shadows all the faults. 193 runs with an average of 64 only second to Chandimal. Congratulations. A.

VC Tamim: Player of the match award says it all. That 49 lbw had a good ending I must say. 200+ runs in 4 innings. He is our Warner. He sets the tone. A

Shakib Al Hasan: A. Player of the series. Determination. Loved you for a thousand years; will love you for a thousand more.

Sarkar: He came, he saw, he took it to them. Future is bright. What a fielder!! A

Fizzzzzzzzzzzzzz: Stay healthy, serve the nation. We are already in debt to you. A.

Mizzzzzzzzzzzz: Future captain. 10 wickets @35 average and 31 average with the bat. A

Mosaddek: (Sohel bhai, ore dak nam ki? - miss you man) Be patient and good things happen to those who remain patient. A

Taijul: Under rated dark horse. A

Roy: Celebrate as there is no tomorrow. Well done. A.

Sabbir: Up / down the order, doesn't matter; 40 per innings. Not bad. Fielding outstanding. A

Imrul: In / Out. New role and everything. Duck and everything. A. (this is reward you deserved for NZ series. Bhulini amra)

Taskin: Unlucky with so many catches dropped. Focus on the next assignment. A.

Mahmudullah/Mominul: Part of the team. Behind the closed doors your encouragements count. A.

hehe or dak nam shubho... he and atimar is on sannaysin contest on who can stay silent the most... both are like gods brahma...the four headed one...meditating on Himalayas for eons....heeeheeeee

Cricket4All · #4 March 19, 2017, 08:27 AM

Ditto !

I completely agree with your grading !

Shaan · #5 March 19, 2017, 08:58 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Tigers_eye
This is totally mine. Make your own and post it if you don't like it.

In the past, mostly I have criticized the teams, captains, coaches, mgmts, fans only for the love of the game. Knowing we could have done better. That being said...

Captain Mushfiq: Whatever the short comings are, you have led us to a series draw at a hostile environment after losing the tosses. Your 2nd innings 6th wicket stand with Shakib of 92 was crucial for this match. 5 dismissals and remaining notout over shadows all the faults. 193 runs with an average of 64 only second to Chandimal. Congratulations. A.

VC Tamim: Player of the match award says it all. That 49 lbw had a good ending I must say. 200+ runs in 4 innings. He is our Warner. He sets the tone. A

Shakib Al Hasan: A. Player of the series. Determination. Loved you for a thousand years; will love you for a thousand more.

Sarkar: He came, he saw, he took it to them. Future is bright. What a fielder!! A

Fizzzzzzzzzzzzzz: Stay healthy, serve the nation. We are already in debt to you. A.

Mizzzzzzzzzzzz: Future captain. 10 wickets @35 average and 31 average with the bat. A

Mosaddek: (Sohel bhai, ore dak nam ki? - miss you man) Be patient and good things happen to those who remain patient. A

Taijul: Under rated dark horse. A

Liton: Showed us what we were missing. Pray get well soon. A

Roy: Celebrate as there is no tomorrow. Well done. A.

Sabbir: Up / down the order, doesn't matter; 40 per innings. Not bad. Fielding outstanding. A

Imrul: In / Out. New role and everything. Duck and everything. A. (this is reward you deserved for NZ series. Bhulini amra)

Taskin: Unlucky with so many catches dropped. Focus on the next assignment. A.

Mahmudullah/Mominul: Part of the team. Behind the closed doors your encouragements count. A.

ditto..
bai, you missed Miraz, he deserves 'A' too for his batting+bowling. He definitely showed us what a good batsman he is in this test series. Our young guns really looking the promising ones, as Nadim says future looking bright

Habib · #6 March 19, 2017, 09:02 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Shaan
ditto..
bai, you missed Miraz, he deserves 'A' too for his batting+bowling. He definitely showed us what a good batsman he is in this test series. Our young guns really looking the promising ones, as Nadim says future looking bright

He didn't miss it. It's the Mizzzzz.

mufi_02 · #7 March 19, 2017, 09:08 AM

what about "fans"? Ekta fans der grade chai TE bhai

SportingBD · #8 March 19, 2017, 09:10 AM

Marks out of 10:

Tamim Iqbal 7.5
Soumya Sarkar 7.0
Imrul Kayes 5.0
Sabbir Rahman 6.5
Shakib Al Hasan 8.5
Mushfiqur Rahim*† 7.5
Mosaddek Hossain 8.0
Mehedi Hasan Miraz 7.0
Taijul Islam 6.0
Subashis Roy 6.0
Mustafizur Rahman 7.5

Rifat · #9 March 19, 2017, 09:20 AM

Saikat is Mosaddek's Pen Name.

Tigers_eye · #10 March 19, 2017, 09:46 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by mufi_02
what about "fans"? Ekta fans der grade chai TE bhai

The only A+ grade they deserve. Critics and well wishers. Without them there is no cricket.

Tigers_eye · #11 March 19, 2017, 09:47 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Rifat
Saikat is Mosaddek's Pen Name.

Thanks. forgot.

Shaan · #12 March 19, 2017, 09:48 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Habib
He didn't miss it. It's the Mizzzzz.

oh i see it's my bad, we have too many fav names sometime get confused

Tigers_eye · #13 March 19, 2017, 09:48 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Zeeshan
hehe or dak nam shubho... he and atimar is on sannaysin contest on who can stay silent the most... both are like gods brahma...the four headed one...meditating on Himalayas for eons....heeeheeeee

lol, was asking for Mosaddek's nick name. He for sure would have answered it correctly.

aklemalp · #14 March 19, 2017, 10:03 AM

Tigers_eye bhai, I would have loved to be in your class...lots of 'A' grades...

Propping up my GPA.

Tigers_eye · #15 March 19, 2017, 10:36 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by aklemalp
Tigers_eye bhai, I would have loved to be in your class...lots of 'A' grades...

Propping up my GPA.

You cheat you get an automatic F. A letter (Hard copy and an email) to the dean.

I did fail few and stopped them from having an MBA degree (sometimes second offense) in my 9 years of teaching. I took the capstone courses. No room for plagiarism was in my class. Stopped it in 2014. Now I just grade players.

aklemalp · #16 March 19, 2017, 10:44 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Tigers_eye
You cheat you get an automatic F. A letter (Hard copy and an email) to the dean.

I did fail few and stopped them from having an MBA degree (sometimes second offense) in my 9 years of teaching. I took the capstone courses. No room for plagiarism was in my class. Stopped it in 2014. Now I just grade players.

Sorry for the off-topic. I'm a good student. I don't do drugs. I sit in front row, ask the professort questions.

On-topic:

Everyone gets a B+

Vepu · #17 March 19, 2017, 11:14 AM

Tamim - 7.5 (instrumental in 2nd test, dissapointing 1st test means missing out on 8)
Soumya - 7.5 ( good series all over bar last innings, good improvement at slip)
Mini- 0
Kayes - 3
Sabbir - 6 ( got starts but needs to convert if he bats at no 4. Opportunities missed)
mahmudulla- 0
Mushy - 8.5 ( excellent batting+keeping)
Shakib - 7 (glimpse of old shakib in 2nd test)
Liton - 7 ( excellent keeper, needs to score more)
Mosa-8 (good nerve)
Miri - 7 (good alround performance)
Roy-6 bowled his heart out
Taskin- 3 (needs to improve)
Musta- 7.5 (game changer)
Taijul- 0 ( nothing bowler)

Gowza · #18 March 19, 2017, 03:36 PM

Sabbir's 4th innings was crucial, imo he's not getting enough credit for it, if he had fallen quickly then this test match might've been won by a different team.

tiger1000 · #19 March 19, 2017, 04:46 PM

Marks out of 10:

Tamim Iqbal 8 - stepped up when it mattered
Soumya Sarkar 7.5
Imrul Kayes 4.0
Sabbir Rahman 7.0
Shakib Al Hasan 8.5 - should be dropped
Mushfiqur Rahim*† 8.0
Mosaddek Hossain 7.0
Mehedi Hasan Miraz 7.0
Taijul Islam 6.0
Subashis Roy 6.0
Mustafizur Rahman 8.0

Taskin 5.5
Mahmadullah 1
Liton 6
Mominul 2

al Furqaan · #20 March 19, 2017, 05:51 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Gowza
Sabbir's 4th innings was crucial, imo he's not getting enough credit for it, if he had fallen quickly then this test match might've been won by a different team.

I had some doubts over Sabbir in the Test team...but he answered that. This was the big knock. This was more important than many of the meaningless-in-the-grand-scheme hundreds that Ashraful, Bashar, and even Tamim have hit in the past.

Tamim's knock was glorious as well. Mushfiq was solid. Shakib and Mosaddek did just enough with the bat to make sure there was no chance for SL (they didn't Mosaddek's wicket as they knew the game was gone by that stage).

Still I want to see Mominul in the top (preferably at #4). Mushy has what it takes to bat at #3. Musa can bat at 5.

Tamim
Soumya (Imrul bench opener)
Mushfiq
Mominul (Sabbir bench)
Mosaddek
Shakib
Nurul/Liton (whoever is better WK-bat)
Miraz
Taijul/Ebadat/Roy/Shahid (Rabbi/Shafiul bench - please no Rubel...EVER)
Taskin
Mustafiz

That is an awesome squad.

Tigers_eye · #21 March 20, 2017, 09:19 AM

Everyone contributed.

Miraz - an unsung hero. His wickets and runs.
Sabbir - 42 and 41 was vital in the second innings.
Taijul - De Silva (set) and Herath wicket were big. Very big in the second innings.
Fizz - As the coach said it was the turning point when nothing was going on. 3 wicket burst in of few overs.

Fazal · #22 March 20, 2017, 09:37 AM

Overall a great Game

Most of the senior players performed and most the the young players contributed. over all not apparent dead woods, what a great overall team. Yes there were some hiccup and frustration, but It was a great overall team performance.

Shingara · #23 March 21, 2017, 04:52 AM

Tamim - 15/20 - A
Soumya - 15/20 - A
Imrul - 3 / 10 - F
Sabbir - 8 / 10 - B
Shakib - 10/20 + 9 - A+
Mushy - 15/20 - A
Mosad - 10/10 - A+
Mehedi - 4/20 +10 - A
Mustafiz - 8 / 20 - A
Roy - 3 / 20 - F
Taijul - 2/10 - F
Taskin - 2/10 - F
Liton - 3 / 10 - F

Fazal · #24 March 21, 2017, 07:55 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Shingara
Tamim - 15/20 - A
Soumya - 15/20 - A
Imrul - 3 / 10 - F
Sabbir - 8 / 10 - B
Shakib - 10/20 + 9 - A+
Mushy - 15/20 - A
Mosad - 10/10 - A+
Mehedi - 4/20 +10 - A
Mustafiz - 8 / 20 - A
Roy - 3 / 20 - F
Taijul - 2/10 - F
Taskin - 2/10 - F
Liton - 3 / 10 - F

Shingara-te morich bedhi..... Imrul, Roy, Taijul, Taskin, Litton all got "F"?

Tigers_eye · #25 March 21, 2017, 09:22 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Shingara
...
Roy - 3 / 20 - F
..
Taskin - 2/10 - F

The drop catches are not their fault. They played their hearts out.

Quote:

Originally Posted by Shingara
Taijul - 2/10 - F

Without Taijul's De Silva and Herath's wicket SL would still be batting.

Quote:

Originally Posted by Shingara
Liton - 3 / 10 - F

You "Mushi the Keeper" fan?

Just felt had to comment. You rreasoning must be solid and you are entitled to that.