My ratings of top 5 Bangladeshi batsmen and bowlers:

[Sadz]

Hi guys, this is my ratings of the current Top 5 Bangladeshi batsmen and Bowlers:
BATSMEN:
1.Mohammad Ashraful
2.Saqibul Hasan
3.Tamim Iqbal
4.Aftab Ahmed
5.Mashrafee Mortaza
BOWLERS
1.Mashrafe Mortaza
2.Abdur Razzak
3.Mohammad Rafique
4.Syed rasel
5.Sakibul Hasan
Thats my views and what do you think? By the way in terms of history in batting I would include Bashar but not on current form. Thanx

[Sohel]

what is your "rating system" based on ? and what may those ratings actually be ?

i think you're talking about a list of favorites here ...

here are mine:

batsmen:

1. Md. Ashraful Matin (talent, technique).
2. Alok Kapali (talent, technique).
3. Tamim Iqbal Khan (talent).
4. Mushfiqur Rahim and Raquibul Hasan Nirala (technique, temperament).
5. Aftab Ahmed Chowdhury and Junaid Siddique (talent).

bowlers:

1. Md. Rafique (superior intelligence, gumption, tenacity).
2. Mashrafe Bin Murtaza (talent, gumption, tenacity).
3. Enamul Haque Jr. (talent, intelligence, tenacity).
4. Shahadat Hossain Rajib (talent, gumption, tenacity).
5. Abdur Razzak (intelligence, gumption, tenacity).

[rah]

SADZ where is rajib or junior?

[nannu]

shahriar nafees is our top batsman maybe not the best.

shahdat deserves a place on top 5

[Sadz]

shahriar nafees is our top batsman maybe not the best.

Sorry mate but remember i sed the performances were based on current form.[/QUOTE]

[Tigers_eye]

My top five:
Batting: (ODIs)
1. Rajib
2. Razzak
3. Mohammad Rafique
4. Mash
5. Mushfiqur Rahim

All these five (our bottom 5) perform better when it matters the most than the top order.

Batting (tests)
1. Rajin
2. Mushfiqur Rahim
3. Mash
4. Sakib
5. Mehrab Jr.

Bowling: (tests)
1. Rajib
2. Razzak
3. Mohammad Rafique
4. Mash
5. Rasel

Bowling (ODIs)
1. Mash
2. Razzak
3. Mohammad Rafique
4. Sakib
5. Rasel

[Nafi]

batsmen (ODI)

1. Md. Ashraful Matin (talent, technique).
2. Tamim Iqbal Khan (talent).
3. Shahriar Nafis
4. Sakibul Hasan (technique, temperament).
5. Aftab Ahmed (talent).

Batting (tests)

1. Javed Omar (Temperament)
2. Habibul Bashar (stats)
3. Mushfiqur Rahim (temperant and technique)
4. Md. Ashraful (Talent, Technique can be temperamental at times)
5. Mashrafee Mortaza (strike power)

bowlers (ODI):

1. Abdur Razzak (intelligence, good turn and bounce).
2. Mashrafe Bin Mortaza (talent, pace, tenacity, bounce).
3. Md. Rafique (intelligence, experience).
4. Syed Rasel (accuracy and bounce)
5. Shahadat Hossain (Pace, bounce and tenacity)

Bowlers (test)

1. Mashrafe Bin Murtaza (talent, pace, tenacity, bounce).
2. Md. Rafique (intelligence, experience).
3. Shahadat Hossain (Pace, bounce and tenacity)
4. Enamul Haque Jr. (talent, intelligence, variation in turn and bounce).
5. Sakibul Hasan (good turn and bounce)

[Mahir]

Batsmen :

Md Ashraful (phenomenal talent)
Tamim Iqbal (superstar in the making)
Aftab Ahmed (devastating when he's on)
Mushfiqur Rahim (SHOULD bat up the order)
Shahriar Nafees (much more than merely a minnow-muncher)

Bowlers :

Mashrafee Mortaza (a real Tiger)
Md Rafique (zealous and enthusiastic ; warrior)
Enamul Haq Jr (talented ; potential match-winner)
Abdur Razzak (consistent contributor)
Syed Rasel (he's a charmer)

The One I respect THE MOST :

Sakib Al Hasan (what a discovery for BD cricket ; true cricketer)

[Rubu]

There is nothing new to say about Kapali, the all time most fortunate player of Bangladesh, so I'm not surprised to see him on many places, but ...

I think a lot of people are over rating Tamim Iqbal. Mind it, the only thing he did so far was to smash a wayward indian bowling, in one innings.

I hope that half century of his does not become the 89* of Kapali, on which he ride on for ever and ever. It is still grooming time for Tamim and we need to make sure he is not flying.

[akabir77]

My best 11 is in SL check them out on 20th