Who should our new captain be?

[Gowza]

Originally Posted by islam1989
riyad did have couplop half century at # 7 and also have century and 90s at #8 , so switich his batting order wont be a big problem in future . he did do the captaincy on 1st BPL on all games , but 2nd edition he gave away for 2 or 3 matches to taylor bcz he thought he wouldbe a better option , but he did the final trick ,under his captaincy they won 2 crucial semifinal games and put the team into the final , and not to forget he is been captaining in NCL , dhaka leage , premeier leage over the years . plus riyad is 4 times more expereinced than nasir if u combined the odi between them , twice in test ,not to mention how many years . i dont have problem with nasir , but he still too young and looks pretty young to the team , if he can continue 1 or 2 more years , than he can become consideration for captain

right so riyad gave up his captaincy because he didn't think he was as good as the other, that's not a good trait to have as a captain.

as far as those couple of half centuries at #7, he's got none batting at #7 in tests, no centuries, no half centuries. his 1 century came batting at #8 and 4 of his 6 half centuries came batting at #8 as well. his test batting average when he bats from 4-7 is 16.21 and that includes the other 2 half centuries he's got in tests so the numbers say he's not very good batting up the order, at least not in tests.

in no way should he be considered as captain in tests, no way at all. has more of a shot in ODIs than any other format, but then his attitude is all wrong to be a captain so imo he should be ruled out completely.

[MHRAM]

No doubt that Shahriar Nafees has a good cricketing brain. I think he has a cool head on his shoulders, but a captain must be able to perform well as a player as well.

If a captain performs, then it lifts the spirit of the team

[ZimSlog]

Ami mane kari Mushy. He will reconsider for sure.

Posted via BC Mobile Edition (Opera Mobile)

[ReZ_1]

Originally Posted by ZimSlog
Ami mane kari Mushy. He will reconsider for sure.

Posted via BC Mobile Edition (Opera Mobile)

[MohammedC]

Jahurul Islam Aumi is a good option. He has done it in NCL.

(NCL FC is not Test Cricket)

[Anher]

I would ask Mushy to continue test captaincy for the time being and appoint Nasir for ODI and T20 captaincy.

[Nadim]

Waiting for Kalker kontho special

[mufi_02]

Shahadat ke ekta chance deya jai.

[Nadim]

Originally Posted by mufi_02
Shahadat ke ekta chance deya jai.

He onek aggresive captain hobe cheleta. Just what we need

Posted via BC Mobile Edition

[pagol-chagol]

Mushfique is by far the best off field organizer, and Shakib is by far the best in field tactician, selector and aggressor. Shakib always perfroms best when he is the captain.

For the current composition of this team, Shakib should be the captain and Mushfique should be the vice captain.

[fwullah]

did anyone think that if mushfique
had a 2nd wicket keeper in the team, then we could have a different result on this tour?

i mean keeping throughout the match and then coming to bat - it was a bit too much; which also includes leading /captaining?

i mean, in the tests, if we had mush come up the order at four -as cool headed batter as he is; the things could have been different? he might have the extra time to think about his bowling strategy etc. etc.

Riyadh, nasir, Tamil, sakib - they are all good options; but i think if mush doesn't reconsider, the n its time for bcb to think about diffrent captains for different formats of the game.

[mehedi]

I would request Mushfique to reconsider his dicision as i feel he is by far the best captain we have ever had. And BCB please don't even think about giving captaincy to tamim and nasir

[mehedi]

[QUOTE=Dilscoop;1702536]For now, 2x time BPL champion Mashrafe Bin Mortaza. He's saving himself for what? Not get injured? Well he's not playing and still getting injured. Just play, retire after WC 15. No point in hanging around.

LOL , Don't know why i could not stop myself from laughing after reading this line

[wktkeeper]

Mash je kobe fit hoibo, Allah e jane. ekbar khep khelte giye paye betha pai, gach theke pore jai. oo ekta kufa

[mufi_02]

Originally Posted by nadim 98
Waiting for Kalker kontho special

nao nadim, tomar special nao

কিন্তু তাতেও মুশফিকুর রহিমের আকস্মিক পদত্যাগ ঘোষণার পেছনে 'বিশেষ' কারণ খোঁজা বন্ধ হয়নি। তাঁর অধীনে একের পর এক দলীয় সাফল্যে ঈর্ষান্বিত হয়ে কেউ 'স্যাবোটাজ' করছেন কি না, এমন সন্দেহের ধোঁয়াও পৌঁছে গেছে ক্রিকেটের অনেক উঁচুতলায়। এ গুঞ্জনের ব্যাপারে দলসংশ্লিষ্ট একজনের মন্তব্য, 'সে রকম কিছু চোখে পড়েনি। তবে কারো মনের ভেতর ঢুকে তো আর খবর নেওয়া যায় না।' বোর্ড সূত্রের খবর, এ ব্যাপারটি তলিয়ে দেখা হবে সহসাই। পিঠে ছুরি হয়তো চালায়নি কেউ; কিন্তু পরোক্ষ অসহযোগিতা তো সিরিজের শুরু থেকেই পেয়েছেন মুশফিক। বারবার একই ভুল করে ব্যাটসম্যানদের উইকেট বিলিয়ে আসায় প্রথম টেস্টের পর ওয়ানডে সিরিজও হেরেছে বাংলাদেশ। এ দায়িত্বজ্ঞানহীন ব্যাটিংও এক ধরনের অসহযোগিতা। সিরিজ হারের পর পরোক্ষে সে রকম ইঙ্গিত দিয়েছেন মুশফিক। ব্যাটিং ভরাডুবির পেছনে অ্যাপ্রোচ এবং স্কিলে সমস্যার সঙ্গে অতি আত্মবিশ্বাসকেও দায়ী করেন তিনি। এ সিরিজে নিজের নৈপুণ্যেও সন্তুষ্ট নন মুশফিক।

http://www.kalerkantho.com/?view=det...e_id=1&index=0

[al-Sagar]

কিন্তু তাতেও মুশফিকুর রহিমের আকস্মিক পদত্যাগ ঘোষণার পেছনে 'বিশেষ' কারণ খোঁজা বন্ধ হয়নি। তাঁর অধীনে একের পর এক দলীয় সাফল্যে ঈর্ষান্বিত হয়ে কেউ 'স্যাবোটাজ' করছেন কি না, এমন সন্দেহের ধোঁয়াও পৌঁছে গেছে ক্রিকেটের অনেক উঁচুতলায়। এ গুঞ্জনের ব্যাপারে দলসংশ্লিষ্ট একজনের মন্তব্য, 'সে রকম কিছু চোখে পড়েনি। তবে কারো মনের ভেতর ঢুকে তো আর খবর নেওয়া যায় না।' বোর্ড সূত্রের খবর, এ ব্যাপারটি তলিয়ে দেখা হবে সহসাই। পিঠে ছুরি হয়তো চালায়নি কেউ; কিন্তু পরোক্ষ অসহযোগিতা তো সিরিজের শুরু থেকেই পেয়েছেন মুশফিক। বারবার একই ভুল করে ব্যাটসম্যানদের উইকেট বিলিয়ে আসায় প্রথম টেস্টের পর ওয়ানডে সিরিজও হেরেছে বাংলাদেশ। এ দায়িত্বজ্ঞানহীন ব্যাটিংও এক ধরনের অসহযোগিতা। সিরিজ হারের পর পরোক্ষে সে রকম ইঙ্গিত দিয়েছেন মুশফিক। ব্যাটিং ভরাডুবির পেছনে অ্যাপ্রোচ এবং স্কিলে সমস্যার সঙ্গে অতি আত্মবিশ্বাসকেও দায়ী করেন তিনি। এ সিরিজে নিজের নৈপুণ্যেও সন্তুষ্ট নন মুশফিক।

this is serious. this is serious.

i dont want those players in the team who intentionally plays bad for a team so that the captain cant get credit for the teams performance.

this needs to be investigated and if such players exist then they should banned.

[simon]

Kaal er kontho shangbadik are dying to accuse Tmim , Sakib for sabotage

[affan_ayan]

"Ian Pont @Ponty100mph

@Bakhtiar_RMD As I said before, best cricket brain is Sharihar Nafees. I'd have him for TESTS (form permitting) and someone else for ODI
9:49 AM - 8 May 2013 from King's Lynn and West Norfolk, Norfolk, United Kingdom"

-Best joke of the year! - The guy who throws his kodal in every innings like an idiot in test match, who is also one of the most senior guy in team?? I doubt he has any ghilu (gray matter) in side the khopri (skull).

[affan_ayan]

Tamim shuru-r dike valo-i chilo, but shakib-er palla-i (and Jamie's guidance) poira, kom boyoshe matha noshto hoe geche. now-a-days be creates more non-cricketing news than a cricketing one.

I think in BD team one guy has brain in between ape and human and he is sir Ash (no doubt possessed with unbelievable talent). And Ash beats Tamim in that respect by a very close mirgin. If we organize our cricketer from ghilu-wise (brain factor), starting with the least ghilu, it would be -

1. Ash (Very close to Ape and barely touches human)
2. Tamim (now-a-days, he makes me even confused, whether he will beat Ash on this)
3. Shahadat (Ravina tendon orofe, SRK)

(Lemme put a gap before, I start 4)

4. Zahurul
5. Razzak
6. Shafiul

(another deliberate gap)
7. Anamul
8. Robiul
9. Mominul
10. Mullah

(another deliberate gap)
11. Mushfiq
12. Shakib
(another deliberate gap)

13. Nasir
14. Mashrafe (I am biased here because he is the best gentle-man and die-hard cricketer for BD)

Overall, Mushfiq is the best due to his extreme hard working mentality, dedication and discipline and above all, academics and education and spirit, love for the game of cricket.

[Gowza]

yes mushy's hard work is a great example to the new call-ups to the team, players should work hard anyway but if the captain is doing then absolutely no excuse not to.

[BanCricFan]

Who should be the new captain?

Mushfiqur Rahim. Simple. He should withdraw his resignation and get re- connected with his rational senses. There is no better person to lead this Bangladeshi side than the Little Fella!

[Roey Haque]

For the 4 people who picked Ash, would it be too much to ask for a reasoned explanation for your choice?

[al-Sagar]

mushfiq leads the race .... with shakib in second position

[Tendulkar_Mcgrath]

Mushy did a mistake by resigning. Mushy is the best option we have.