Rate the Umpiring in BD vs NZ series (2013)

[MohammedC]

We are always the first to criticise when umpire makes bad decision but I think the umpiring has been excellent this series. First time after a long time we were not victimised because of our ranking position.

Thanks ICC and Umpire panel. Keep up your good work.

[simon]

9/10
full marks dilam na, full marks na diley nijeke inteleksual lagey.

[MohammedC]

Originally Posted by simon
9/10
full marks dilam na, full marks na diley nijeke inteleksual lagey.

I think I agree with you. They probably missed few close LBW's but nothing serious.

[shuziburo]

A few close LBW and Riyad's 'catch.' But, no howler!

8.5/10.

[Moh899]

Umpiring been up to the mark in this series. No complains here.

[NoName]

Really good!

[roman]

Originally Posted by shuziburo
A few close LBW and Riyad's 'catch.' But, no howler!

8.5/10.

Riyad's catch was referred to 3rd umpire if I am not mistaken. 3rd umpire was a desi guy. Luckily that decision didn't cost us that match..

I was worried about Moni's performance to be honest, but he did a fair job. Overall, satisfied

[moneymoney]

No Ashoka No Cry

[MHRAM]

the umpiring in the test and first 2 ODIs were good

the two Bangladeshi umpires in the last 2 matches were substandard

Posted via BC Mobile Edition

[Naimul_Hd]

No complaints. Good work by all the umpires. Hope they will continue their good work.

[kalpurush]

Originally Posted by roman
Riyad's catch was referred to 3rd umpire if I am not mistaken. 3rd umpire was a desi guy. Luckily that decision didn't cost us that match..

I was worried about Moni's performance to be honest, but he did a fair job. Overall, satisfied

International Vice-Captain

---

Join Date:Oct 2010

Location: Auckland

Posts: 4,489

Banger umpires are going to cost bangers the game haha!

^^^from a Kiwi forum!
http://www.cricketweb.net/forum/cric...013-a-148.html

[cricketboy]

Anisur Rahman was horrible in the 20-20. First he gave a wide when batsman switched from left hander to right-hander and Mushy was very angry with that. He also gave few leg byes which touched the bat and few runs which should have been leg byes. He also looked very nervous and prone to make the wrong decision.

[MohammedC]

So most of the mistakes made by our own. At least the neutral umpiring was good.

[RazabQ]

The umpiring was the best that I've seen involving us. Consistent. If questionable LBWs were denied for us, same applied to NZ. Some really good quality decisions made w/o DRS or multiple slo-mo cameras. Easiest way to think about it is that umps were hardly the topic after match end. That's the mark of good umpiring.

[Ashfaq]

We were victimized less, but the overall quality of umpiring left something to be desired. Several questionable decisions have been made involving both teams. Fortunately our bowlers created more chances.