Seriously why Ashwin's action has not been tested yet?

[Kohli_Sox]

Watching SL vs India. The amount of variation he is achieving is not impossible within limit. If he is tested and comes clean, let him bowl all his variations. While I think his natural off spin deliveries are fairly ok but there is some sort of doubt in others. Pretty sure if he was from any other country than India, he would have been tested by ICC already.

[vayuu1]

Originally Posted by Kohli_Sox
Watching SL vs India. The amount of variation he is achieving is not impossible within limit. If he is tested and comes clean, let him bowl all his variations. While I think his natural off spin deliveries are fairly ok but there is some sort of doubt in others. Pretty sure if he was from any other country than India, he would have been tested by ICC already.

His action is much better than mustafizur rehman and hom.

[Kohli_Sox]

Originally Posted by vayuu1
His action is much better than mustafizur rehman and hom.

Test it then.

[horizon]

Originally Posted by Kohli_Sox
Watching SL vs India. The amount of variation he is achieving is not impossible within limit. If he is tested and comes clean, let him bowl all his variations. While I think his natural off spin deliveries are fairly ok but there is some sort of doubt in others. Pretty sure if he was from any other country than India, he would have been tested by ICC already.

He stopped bowling dusras if I were correct. Only variation he has is the carrom ball, which is delivered with a different action and could be picked up by watchful batsmen. The other carrom ball bowler Mendis was never called for action yet.

[Krishna]

'Just because a spin bowler has good variations in his bowling he must go through test.'

So you mean generally a finger spinner can't have much variations without bending his arm less than 90° angle.
The logic itself seems to be less logical..

[vayuu1]

Originally Posted by Kohli_Sox
Test it then.

Be my guest .

[Mas_UK25]

Originally Posted by vayuu1
His action is much better than mustafizur rehman and hom.

Mustafizur has the world record taking 5fer and 6fer in his first two ODI games, that to was against the mighty Indian batting line up. PWNAGE

[Donal C]

Always love when people accuse him of chucking when he's clearly clean.

[NoName]

If Mustafizur is a chucker he would have been reported, flagged then banned right after the first ODI against India

Anyways I don't think Ashwin is a chucker

[vayuu1]

Originally Posted by Mas_UK25
Mustafizur has the world record taking 5fer and 6fer in his first two ODI games, that to was against the mighty Indian batting line up. PWNAGE

The chat is about action not record genius.

[jeesh]

Ashwins action is clean, but on and off i ve seen him bowl deliveries which would have been flagged if it was someone from any other country.

Recently when the actions of off spinners were under scrutiny, India mysteriously "Rested" Ashwin from a particular series.

Its an inconvenient truth, but ICC will not poke the bear.

[Yameen]

Ashwin is clean guys.

Don't know why we get so much chulkhani about Indian spinners not getting called for illegal actions. If I remember correctly Ojha was called but the main reason their spinners at senior level get rarely called is because they have a rigorous system at youth/junior level to filter out and correct any dubious actions from a young age.

[vayuu1]

Originally Posted by Yameen
Ashwin is clean guys.

Don't know why we get so much chulkhani about Indian spinners not getting called for illegal actions. If I remember correctly Ojha was called but the main reason their spinners at senior level get rarely called is because they have a rigorous system at youth/junior level to filter out and correct any dubious actions from a young age.

exactly.

[vayuu1]

I'll tell you a real story a guy called mohnish parmar, who use to turn the ball miles and guy called kamran khan their carriers were destroyed because of chucking allegations, not to forget Ojha as well, even bhaji isn't the same bowler since his doosra got banned.

[vayuu1]

Regarding Ashwin, he has sorted his bowling as he use to bowl quicker and use to bowl carrom bowl, but since world cup he is a different bowler, who relies more on offies, while mixing it with occasional under cutters, seam ups , arm ball ,carrom ball and a rare leg spin, also varies his pace and length cleverly, even with slightest of turn he can be all over you.

[tiger1000]

Ashwin seems clean, seen him bowl few chucks, but most spinners may bowl few chucks a game

[horizon]

Originally Posted by Yameen
Ashwin is clean guys.

Don't know why we get so much chulkhani about Indian spinners not getting called for illegal actions. If I remember correctly Ojha was called but the main reason their spinners at senior level get rarely called is because they have a rigorous system at youth/junior level to filter out and correct any dubious actions from a young age.

There are three institutes for testing bowling actions - they are in England, Aus and India. Not surprisingly, these three teams don't have many spinners accused. If you follow Indian domestic, every season there are handful of bowlers taken out.