Should Mushfiqur keep on keeping?

[meazz1]

Originally Posted by simon
I disagree on any other option instead of Mushy.
Anam is a new comer who is trying to establish himself as an opener or a top order btsmn, giving him the gloves is not going to help.
Dhiman is hopeless to me.
Besides Mushy is doing a fine job.
So why fixing something which isn't broken?

Why do you think he is hopeless? From BC forum here, I got the idea that he is a better keeper than Mushy. A lot of us wanted Dhiman to take up keeping and Mushy to focus on batting only.
Did you base your opinion because what he had said in the ICL time?

I only saw one match he kept against AUS so I don't have much to go by here.

[simon]

Originally Posted by shuziburo
Really? Aren't wicketkeepers supposed to hold on to catches?

apart from that T20 he didn't drop any throughout this series as far as I remember.

Originally Posted by meazz1
Why do you think he is hopeless? From BC forum here, I got the idea that he is a better keeper than Mushy. A lot of us wanted Dhiman to take up keeping and Mushy to focus on batting only.
Did you base your opinion because what he had said in the ICL time?

I only saw one match he kept against AUS so I don't have much to go by here.

I saw him last time which was probably when Aus visited, he looked nervous & shaky.


Anyway,I think dropping one or two catches happens to every wicket keeper, just because it's Mushy we go overboard with it.

[Shaan]

Originally Posted by simon
apart from that T20 he didn't drop any throughout this series as far as I remember.



I saw him last time which was probably when Aus visited, he looked nervous & shaky.


Anyway,I think dropping one or two catches happens to every wicket keeper, just because it's Mushy we go overboard with it.

yes I agree with you look at current India vs Eng test Dhoni and Prior both dropped easy catches.. so why we are complaining all the time about Rahim. Why not talking about his some good catches, some of them were at a time brilliant. I think Rahim is the best keeper what we have right now.

[shuziburo]

Originally Posted by simon
apart from that T20 he didn't drop any throughout this series as far as I remember.

Anyway,I think dropping one or two catches happens to every wicket keeper, just because it's Mushy we go overboard with it.

If my memory serves me right, he dropped Bravo in the 4th ODI. He also allowed a number of bye and leg-bye fours that should have been stopped.

Everyone drops catches, but competent ones drop less. Mushfiqur drops more.